Commit Graph

8 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Brian Behlendorf
82a37189aa Implement SA based xattrs
The current ZFS implementation stores xattrs on disk using a hidden
directory.  In this directory a file name represents the xattr name
and the file contexts are the xattr binary data.  This approach is
very flexible and allows for arbitrarily large xattrs.  However,
it also suffers from a significant performance penalty.  Accessing
a single xattr can requires up to three disk seeks.

  1) Lookup the dnode object.
  2) Lookup the dnodes's xattr directory object.
  3) Lookup the xattr object in the directory.

To avoid this performance penalty Linux filesystems such as ext3
and xfs try to store the xattr as part of the inode on disk.  When
the xattr is to large to store in the inode then a single external
block is allocated for them.  In practice most xattrs are small
and this approach works well.

The addition of System Attributes (SA) to zfs provides us a clean
way to make this optimization.  When the dataset property 'xattr=sa'
is set then xattrs will be preferentially stored as System Attributes.
This allows tiny xattrs (~100 bytes) to be stored with the dnode and
up to 64k of xattrs to be stored in the spill block.  If additional
xattr space is required, which is unlikely under Linux, they will be
stored using the traditional directory approach.

This optimization results in roughly a 3x performance improvement
when accessing xattrs which brings zfs roughly to parity with ext4
and xfs (see table below).  When multiple xattrs are stored per-file
the performance improvements are even greater because all of the
xattrs stored in the spill block will be cached.

However, by default SA based xattrs are disabled in the Linux port
to maximize compatibility with other implementations.  If you do
enable SA based xattrs then they will not be visible on platforms
which do not support this feature.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
   Time in seconds to get/set one xattr of N bytes on 100,000 files
------+--------------------------------+------------------------------
      |            setxattr            |            getxattr
bytes |  ext4     xfs zfs-dir  zfs-sa  |  ext4     xfs zfs-dir  zfs-sa
------+--------------------------------+------------------------------
1     |  2.33   31.88   21.50    4.57  |  2.35    2.64    6.29    2.43
32    |  2.79   30.68   21.98    4.60  |  2.44    2.59    6.78    2.48
256   |  3.25   31.99   21.36    5.92  |  2.32    2.71    6.22    3.14
1024  |  3.30   32.61   22.83    8.45  |  2.40    2.79    6.24    3.27
4096  |  3.57  317.46   22.52   10.73  |  2.78   28.62    6.90    3.94
16384 |   n/a 2342.39   34.30   19.20  |   n/a   45.44  145.90    7.55
65536 |   n/a 2941.39  128.15  131.32* |   n/a  141.92  256.85  262.12*

Legend:
* ext4      - Stock RHEL6.1 ext4 mounted with '-o user_xattr'.
* xfs       - Stock RHEL6.1 xfs mounted with default options.
* zfs-dir   - Directory based xattrs only.
* zfs-sa    - Prefer SAs but spill in to directories as needed, a
              trailing * indicates overflow in to directories occured.

NOTE: Ext4 supports 4096 bytes of xattr name/value pairs per file.
NOTE: XFS and ZFS have no limit on xattr name/value pairs per file.
NOTE: Linux limits individual name/value pairs to 65536 bytes.
NOTE: All setattr/getattr's were done after dropping the cache.
NOTE: All tests were run against a single hard drive.

Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov>
Issue #443
2011-11-28 15:45:51 -08:00
Brian Behlendorf
2cf7f52bc4 Linux compat 2.6.39: mount_nodev()
The .get_sb callback has been replaced by a .mount callback
in the file_system_type structure.  When using the new
interface the caller must now use the mount_nodev() helper.

Unfortunately, the new interface no longer passes the vfsmount
down to the zfs layers.  This poses a problem for the existing
implementation because we currently save this pointer in the
super block for latter use.  It provides our only entry point
in to the namespace layer for manipulating certain mount options.

This needed to be done originally to allow commands like
'zfs set atime=off tank' to work properly.  It also allowed me
to keep more of the original Solaris code unmodified.  Under
Solaris there is a 1-to-1 mapping between a mount point and a
file system so this is a fairly natural thing to do.  However,
under Linux they many be multiple entries in the namespace
which reference the same filesystem.  Thus keeping a back
reference from the filesystem to the namespace is complicated.

Rather than introduce some ugly hack to get the vfsmount and
continue as before.  I'm leveraging this API change to update
the ZFS code to do things in a more natural way for Linux.
This has the upside that is resolves the compatibility issue
for the long term and fixes several other minor bugs which
have been reported.

This commit updates the code to remove this vfsmount back
reference entirely.  All modifications to filesystem mount
options are now passed in to the kernel via a '-o remount'.
This is the expected Linux mechanism and allows the namespace
to properly handle any options which apply to it before passing
them on to the file system itself.

Aside from fixing the compatibility issue, removing the
vfsmount has had the benefit of simplifying the code.  This
change which fairly involved has turned out nicely.

Closes #246
Closes #217
Closes #187
Closes #248
Closes #231
2011-07-01 13:36:39 -07:00
Brian Behlendorf
5c03efc379 Linux compat 2.6.39: security_inode_init_security()
The security_inode_init_security() function now takes an additional
qstr argument which must be passed in from the dentry if available.
Passing a NULL is safe when no qstr is available the relevant
security checks will just be skipped.

Closes #246
Closes #217
Closes #187
2011-07-01 12:40:08 -07:00
Gunnar Beutner
bec30953cd Truncate the xattr znode when updating existing attributes.
If the attribute's new value was shorter than the old one the old
code would leave parts of the old value in the xattr znode.

Signed-off-by: Brian Behlendorf <behlendorf1@llnl.gov>
Closes #203
2011-04-19 14:14:40 -07:00
Brian Behlendorf
81e97e2187 Linux 2.6.29 compat, credentials
As of Linux 2.6.29 a clean credential API was added to the Linux kernel.
Previously the credential was embedded in the task_struct.  Because the
SPL already has considerable support for handling this API change the
ZPL code has been updated to use the Solaris credential API.
2011-03-22 12:15:54 -07:00
Brian Behlendorf
f9637c6c8b Linux 2.6.33 compat, get/set xattr callbacks
The xattr handler prototypes were sanitized with the idea being that
the same handlers could be used for multiple methods.  The result of
this was the inode type was changes to a dentry, and both the get()
and set() hooks had a handler_flags argument added.  The list()
callback was similiarly effected but no autoconf check was added
because we do not use the list() callback.
2011-02-11 10:41:00 -08:00
Brian Behlendorf
777d4af891 Linux 2.6.35 compat, const struct xattr_handler
The const keyword was added to the 'struct xattr_handler' in the
generic Linux super_block structure.  To handle this we define an
appropriate xattr_handler_t typedef which can be used.  This was
the preferred solution because it keeps the code clean and readable.
2011-02-10 16:29:00 -08:00
Brian Behlendorf
cc5f931cfd Add Hooks for Linux Xattr Operations
The Linux specific xattr operations have all been located in the
file zpl_xattr.c.  These functions primarily rely on the reworked
zfs_* functions to do their job.  They are also responsible for
converting the possible Solaris style error codes to negative
Linux errors.
2011-02-10 09:27:21 -08:00