Commit Graph

60 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Warner Losh
89c81b88f1 Revert junk from last commit. These are WIP and not ready (and don't
match the description of the last commit).
2009-05-20 22:00:39 +00:00
Warner Losh
00b4e54ae7 We no longer need to use d_thread_t, migrate to struct thread *. 2009-05-20 17:29:21 +00:00
Warner Losh
9dffe835eb Don't adjust ranges at all for subtractive bridges. The simple-minded
stuff we're doing is too simple-minded, so back it out for now.
2009-03-15 06:40:57 +00:00
Warner Losh
795dceffa2 Two fixes:
(1) Fix pcib_read/write_config prototypes.
(2) When contrainting a resource request for a 'subtractive' bridge,
    it is important to select a range outside the base/limit
    registers, since those are the only values known to not
    possibly work.  On my HP laptop, the base bridge excludes I/O
    ports 0xa000-0xafff, however that was the range we were passing
    up the tree.  Instead, when a range spans the "hole" we now
    arbitrarily pick the range just above the hole to allocate from.

All of my rl and xl cards, at a minimum, started working again on this
laptop with those fixes.
2009-03-14 14:08:53 +00:00
Warner Losh
7589f19e81 Style nit. Continued lines are indented 2 spaces in this file. 2008-09-03 06:57:21 +00:00
John Baldwin
9c0e9e988e The config space registers holding the upper 32-bits of the prefetchable
memory area's base and limit are optional.  The low 4-bits of the "low"
prefetchable registers indicates whether or not a 32-bit or 64-bit
region is supported.  The PCI-PCI driver had been assuming that all bridges
supported a 64-bit region (and thus the two upper 32-bit registers).  Fix
the driver to only use those registers if the low 4-bits of the "low"
registers indicate that a 64-bit region is supported.  The PCI-PCI bridge
in the XBox happens to be a bridge that only supports a 32-bit region.

Reported by:	rink
MFC after:	1 week
2008-08-20 18:29:59 +00:00
Warner Losh
7e178674ff Update a comment about not numbering pci busses. This may soon be
OBE, but was sitting around in one of my trees for a while...
2008-08-17 17:34:07 +00:00
Warner Losh
e4e130244d Remove useless #if 1. 2008-08-16 21:51:54 +00:00
Warner Losh
abf07f13fd Add some sysctl reporting for most pci_pci bridges. We now report
domain, pribus (the primary bus, eg the bus that this chip is on),
secbus (the secondary bus, eg the bus immediately behind this chip)
and subbus (the number of the highest bus behind this chip).
Normally, this information is reported via bootverbose parameters, but
that's hard to use for debugging in some cases.

This adds reading of pribus to make this happen.  In addition, change
the narrow types to u_int to allow for easier reporting via sysctl for
domain, secbus and subbus.  This should have no effect, but if it
does, please let me know.
2008-08-16 20:18:40 +00:00
Luoqi Chen
4522ac77de SATA device on some nForce based boards could get confused if MSI is not
used but MSI to HyperTransport IRQ mapping is enabled, and would act as
if MSI is turned on, resulting in interrupt loss.

This commit will,
1. enable MSI mapping on a device only when MSI is enabled for that
   device and the MSI address matches the HT mapping window.
2. enable MSI mapping on a bridge only when a downstream device is
   allocated an MSI address in the mapping window

PR:		kern/118842
Reviewed by:	jhb
MFC after:	1 week
2008-07-23 09:44:36 +00:00
Marius Strobl
55aaf894e8 Make the PCI code aware of PCI domains (aka PCI segments) so we can
support machines having multiple independently numbered PCI domains
and don't support reenumeration without ambiguity amongst the
devices as seen by the OS and represented by PCI location strings.
This includes introducing a function pci_find_dbsf(9) which works
like pci_find_bsf(9) but additionally takes a domain number argument
and limiting pci_find_bsf(9) to only search devices in domain 0 (the
only domain in single-domain systems). Bge(4) and ofw_pcibus(4) are
changed to use pci_find_dbsf(9) instead of pci_find_bsf(9) in order
to no longer report false positives when searching for siblings and
dupe devices in the same domain respectively.
Along with this change the sole host-PCI bridge driver converted to
actually make use of PCI domain support is uninorth(4), the others
continue to use domain 0 only for now and need to be converted as
appropriate later on.
Note that this means that the format of the location strings as used
by pciconf(8) has been changed and that consumers of <sys/pciio.h>
potentially need to be recompiled.

Suggested by:	jhb
Reviewed by:	grehan, jhb, marcel
Approved by:	re (kensmith), jhb (PCI maintainer hat)
2007-09-30 11:05:18 +00:00
Andrew Gallatin
bd82bbb145 Fix a typo in pcib_alloc_msi{x} which resulted in the
device's, not the bridge's, softc to be used to check the
PCIB_DISABLE_MSI flag.  This resulted in randomly allowing
or denying MSI interrupts based on whatever value the driver
happened to store at sizeof(device_t) bytes into its softc.

I noticed this when I stopped getting MSI interrupts
after slighly re-arranging mxge's softc yesterday.
2007-05-23 15:31:00 +00:00
John Baldwin
e706f7f0c7 Revamp the MSI/MSI-X code a bit to achieve two main goals:
- Simplify the amount of work that has be done for each architecture by
  pushing more of the truly MI code down into the PCI bus driver.
- Don't bind MSI-X indicies to IRQs so that we can allow a driver to map
  multiple MSI-X messages into a single IRQ when handling a message
  shortage.

The changes include:
- Add a new pcib_if method: PCIB_MAP_MSI() which is called by the PCI bus
  to calculate the address and data values for a given MSI/MSI-X IRQ.
  The x86 nexus drivers map this into a call to a new 'msi_map()' function
  in msi.c that does the mapping.
- Retire the pcib_if method PCIB_REMAP_MSIX() and remove the 'index'
  parameter from PCIB_ALLOC_MSIX().  MD code no longer has any knowledge
  of the MSI-X index for a given MSI-X IRQ.
- The PCI bus driver now stores more MSI-X state in a child's ivars.
  Specifically, it now stores an array of IRQs (called "message vectors" in
  the code) that have associated address and data values, and a small
  virtual version of the MSI-X table that specifies the message vector
  that a given MSI-X table entry uses.  Sparse mappings are permitted in
  the virtual table.
- The PCI bus driver now configures the MSI and MSI-X address/data
  registers directly via custom bus_setup_intr() and bus_teardown_intr()
  methods.  pci_setup_intr() invokes PCIB_MAP_MSI() to determine the
  address and data values for a given message as needed.  The MD code
  no longer has to call back down into the PCI bus code to set these
  values from the nexus' bus_setup_intr() handler.
- The PCI bus code provides a callout (pci_remap_msi_irq()) that the MD
  code can call to force the PCI bus to re-invoke PCIB_MAP_MSI() to get
  new values of the address and data fields for a given IRQ.  The x86
  MSI code uses this when an MSI IRQ is moved to a different CPU, requiring
  a new value of the 'address' field.
- The x86 MSI psuedo-driver loses a lot of code, and in fact the separate
  MSI/MSI-X pseudo-PICs are collapsed down into a single MSI PIC driver
  since the only remaining diff between the two is a substring in a
  bootverbose printf.
- The PCI bus driver will now restore MSI-X state (including programming
  entries in the MSI-X table) on device resume.
- The interface for pci_remap_msix() has changed.  Instead of accepting
  indices for the allocated vectors, it accepts a mini-virtual table
  (with a new length parameter).  This table is an array of u_ints, where
  each value specifies which allocated message vector to use for the
  corresponding MSI-X message.  A vector of 0 forces a message to not
  have an associated IRQ.  The device may choose to only use some of the
  IRQs assigned, in which case the unused IRQs must be at the "end" and
  will be released back to the system.  This allows a driver to use the
  same remap table for different shortage values.  For example, if a driver
  wants 4 messages, it can use the same remap table (which only uses the
  first two messages) for the cases when it only gets 2 or 3 messages and
  in the latter case the PCI bus will release the 3rd IRQ back to the
  system.

MFC after:	1 month
2007-05-02 17:50:36 +00:00
John Baldwin
657d9f9f55 - Add missing constants for subclasses.
- Add a few progif constants as well.
2007-03-31 20:41:00 +00:00
John Baldwin
5fe82bca57 Expand the MSI/MSI-X API to address some deficiencies in the MSI-X support.
- First off, device drivers really do need to know if they are allocating
  MSI or MSI-X messages.  MSI requires allocating powerof2() messages for
  example where MSI-X does not.  To address this, split out the MSI-X
  support from pci_msi_count() and pci_alloc_msi() into new driver-visible
  functions pci_msix_count() and pci_alloc_msix().  As a result,
  pci_msi_count() now just returns a count of the max supported MSI
  messages for the device, and pci_alloc_msi() only tries to allocate MSI
  messages.  To get a count of the max supported MSI-X messages, use
  pci_msix_count().  To allocate MSI-X messages, use pci_alloc_msix().
  pci_release_msi() still handles both MSI and MSI-X messages, however.
  As a result of this change, drivers using the existing API will only
  use MSI messages and will no longer try to use MSI-X messages.
- Because MSI-X allows for each message to have its own data and address
  values (and thus does not require all of the messages to have their
  MD vectors allocated as a group), some devices allow for "sparse" use
  of MSI-X message slots.  For example, if a device supports 8 messages
  but the OS is only able to allocate 2 messages, the device may make the
  best use of 2 IRQs if it enables the messages at slots 1 and 4 rather
  than default of using the first N slots (or indicies) at 1 and 2.  To
  support this, add a new pci_remap_msix() function that a driver may call
  after a successful pci_alloc_msix() (but before allocating any of the
  SYS_RES_IRQ resources) to allow the allocated IRQ resources to be
  assigned to different message indices.  For example, from the earlier
  example, after pci_alloc_msix() returned a value of 2, the driver would
  call pci_remap_msix() passing in array of integers { 1, 4 } as the
  new message indices to use.  The rid's for the SYS_RES_IRQ resources
  will always match the message indices.  Thus, after the call to
  pci_remap_msix() the driver would be able to access the first message
  in slot 1 at SYS_RES_IRQ rid 1, and the second message at slot 4 at
  SYS_RES_IRQ rid 4.  Note that the message slots/indices are 1-based
  rather than 0-based so that they will always correspond to the rid
  values (SYS_RES_IRQ rid 0 is reserved for the legacy INTx interrupt).
  To support this API, a new PCIB_REMAP_MSIX() method was added to the
  pcib interface to change the message index for a single IRQ.

Tested by:	scottl
2007-01-22 21:48:44 +00:00
John Baldwin
22bf1c7fb0 - Add a new flag to the PCI-PCI driver to disable MSI on devices behind the
bridge if it doesn't pass MSI messages up correctly.  We set the flag
  in pcib_attach() if the device ID is disabled via a PCI quirk.
- Disable MSI for devices behind the AMD 8131 HT-PCIX bridge.  Linux has
  the same quirk.

Tested by:	no one despite repeated calls for testers
2007-01-13 04:57:37 +00:00
John Baldwin
9bf4c9c1b0 First cut at MI support for PCI Message Signalled Interrupts (MSI):
- Add 3 new functions to the pci_if interface along with suitable wrappers
  to provide the device driver visible API:
  - pci_alloc_msi(dev, int *count) backed by PCI_ALLOC_MSI().  '*count'
    here is an in and out parameter.  The driver stores the desired number
    of messages in '*count' before calling the function.  On success,
    '*count' holds the number of messages allocated to the device.  Also on
    success, the driver can access the messages as SYS_RES_IRQ resources
    starting at rid 1.  Note that the legacy INTx interrupt resource will
    not be available when using MSI.  Note that this function will allocate
    either MSI or MSI-X messages depending on the devices capabilities and
    the 'hw.pci.enable_msix' and 'hw.pci.enable_msi' tunables.  Also note
    that the driver should activate the memory resource that holds the
    MSI-X table and pending bit array (PBA) before calling this function
    if the device supports MSI-X.
  - pci_release_msi(dev) backed by PCI_RELEASE_MSI().  This function
    releases the messages allocated for this device.  All of the
    SYS_RES_IRQ resources need to be released for this function to succeed.
  - pci_msi_count(dev) backed by PCI_MSI_COUNT().  This function returns
    the maximum number of MSI or MSI-X messages supported by this device.
    MSI-X is preferred if present, but this function will honor the
    'hw.pci.enable_msix' and 'hw.pci.enable_msi' tunables.  This function
    should return the largest value that pci_alloc_msi() can return
    (assuming the MD code is able to allocate sufficient backing resources
    for all of the messages).
- Add default implementations for these 3 methods to the pci_driver generic
  PCI bus driver.  (The various other PCI bus drivers such as for ACPI and
  OFW will inherit these default implementations.)  This default
  implementation depends on 4 new pcib_if methods that bubble up through
  the PCI bridges to the MD code to allocate IRQ values and perform any
  needed MD setup code needed:
  - PCIB_ALLOC_MSI() attempts to allocate a group of MSI messages.
  - PCIB_RELEASE_MSI() releases a group of MSI messages.
  - PCIB_ALLOC_MSIX() attempts to allocate a single MSI-X message.
  - PCIB_RELEASE_MSIX() releases a single MSI-X message.
- Add default implementations for these 4 methods that just pass the
  request up to the parent bus's parent bridge driver and use the
  default implementation in the various MI PCI bridge drivers.
- Add MI functions for use by MD code when managing MSI and MSI-X
  interrupts:
  - pci_enable_msi(dev, address, data) programs the MSI capability address
    and data registers for a group of MSI messages
  - pci_enable_msix(dev, index, address, data) initializes a single MSI-X
    message in the MSI-X table
  - pci_mask_msix(dev, index) masks a single MSI-X message
  - pci_unmask_msix(dev, index) unmasks a single MSI-X message
  - pci_pending_msix(dev, index) returns true if the specified MSI-X
    message is currently pending
- Save the MSI capability address and data registers in the pci_cfgreg
  block in a PCI devices ivars and restore the values when a device is
  resumed.  Note that the MSI-X table is not currently restored during
  resume.
- Add constants for MSI-X register offsets and fields.
- Record interesting data about any MSI-X capability blocks we come
  across in the pci_cfgreg block in the ivars for PCI devices.

Tested on:	em (i386, MSI), bce (amd64/i386, MSI), mpt (amd64, MSI-X)
Reviewed by:	scottl, grehan, jfv
MFC after:	2 months
2006-11-13 21:47:30 +00:00
John Baldwin
2604383634 Don't try to print a NULL string during boot. If a device doesn't have a
valid name yet, just omit the name during the bootverbose printfs.

MFC after:	1 week
2006-11-09 18:04:53 +00:00
Warner Losh
b0a2d4b8a9 More fully support 64-bit bars. Prior to this commit, we supported
only those bars that had addresses assigned by the BIOS and where the
bridges were properly programmed.  Now even unprogrammed ones work.
This was needed for sun4v.  We still only implement up to 2GB memory
ranges, even for 64-bit bars.  PCI standards at least through 2.2 say
that this is the max (or 1GB is, I only know it is < 32bits).

o Always define pci_addr_t as uint64_t.  A pci address is always 64-bits,
  but some hosts can't address all of them.
o Preserve the upper half of the 64-bit word during resource probing.
o Test to make sure that 64-bit values can fit in a u_long (true on some
  platforms, but not others).  Don't use those that can't.
o minor pedantry about data sizes.
o Better bridge resource reporting in bootverbose case.
o Minor formatting changes to cope with different data types on different
  platforms.

Submitted by: jmg, with many changes by me to fully support 64-bit
addresses.
2006-10-30 19:18:46 +00:00
Warner Losh
413d6375d7 Remove redundant casts. The casts inside the macros should be
sufficient (or fixed if not).
2006-10-12 03:05:45 +00:00
Jung-uk Kim
1def0ca64d Free allocated environment variables after use.
Coverity ID:	366
Found by:	Coverity Prevent
2006-04-21 19:35:03 +00:00
John Baldwin
04dda605c5 - Make pcib_devclass private to sys/dev/pci/pci_pci.c and change all the
various pcib drivers to use their own private devclass_t variables for
  their modules.
- Use the DEFINE_CLASS_0() macro to declare drivers for the various pcib
  drivers while I'm here.
2006-01-06 19:22:19 +00:00
Jung-uk Kim
c94d6dbee5 fix CardBus issue for Compaq R3000 series laptop
Approved by:	anholt (mentor)
2005-08-26 23:39:44 +00:00
Warner Losh
4e30440d7c Add a detach for pci bridge and pci bus drivers. This allows one to
theoretically unload pci bridges or pci drivers.  It will also allow
detach to work if one needed to detach a subtree.

This is inspired by looking at the p4 commits from bms to his 5.4
tree, but I didn't look at the final results.
2005-04-29 06:22:41 +00:00
Marcel Moolenaar
d98d9b126b In pcib_alloc_resource() check if the resource allocation request is
for the VGA I/O or memory ranges, when it's not within the default
ranges decoded by the bridge. When allocation for VGA addresses is
attempted, check that the bridge has the VGA Enable bit set before
allowing it.
As such, newbusified VGA drivers can allocate their resources when
the VGA adapter is behind a PCI-to-PCI bridge.

Reviewed by: imp@, jhb@
2005-04-29 02:15:40 +00:00
John Baldwin
5165a17df5 Add code to read the primary PCI bus number out of the Compaq/HP 6010
hotplug Host to PCI bridge.  This is only needed for the non-ACPI case
as the BIOS includes a proper _BBN method in ACPI.
2005-03-25 14:18:50 +00:00
Warner Losh
2daa7a07ae For the I/O port case, we need to set ok to 1 if we have what looks
like a valid range.  We already do this in the memory case (although
the code there is somewhat different than the I/o case because we have
to deal with different kinds of memory).  Since most laptops don't
have non-subtractive bridges, this wasn't seen in practice.

Evidentally the Compaq R3000 hits this problem with PC Cards.

Some minor style fixes while I'm here.

Submitted by: Jung-uk Kim
2005-02-18 17:35:03 +00:00
John Baldwin
39981fed82 Trim a few things from the dmesg output and stick them under bootverbose to
cut down on the clutter including PCI interrupt routing, MTRR, pcibios,
etc.

Discussed with:	USENIX Cabal
2004-07-01 07:46:29 +00:00
Poul-Henning Kamp
41ee9f1c69 Add some missing <sys/module.h> includes which are masked by the
one on death-row in <sys/kernel.h>
2004-05-30 17:57:46 +00:00
Warner Losh
cd8b53ed2d Omnibus PCI commit:
o Save and restore bars for suspend/resume as well as for D3->D0
	  transitions.
	o preallocate resources that the PCI devices use to avoid resource
	  conflicts
	o lazy allocation of resources not allocated by the BIOS.
	o set unattached drivers to state D3.  Set power state to D0
	  before probe/attach.  Right now there's two special cases
	  for this (display and memory devices) that need work in other
	  areas of the tree.

Please report any bugs to me.
2004-04-09 15:44:34 +00:00
Warner Losh
70be398070 It appears that the changes in the resources allocated is causing much
pain and suffering.  Attempt to back it out by removing the 'if the
requested range is larger than the window, clip to the window' code.
This is a band-aide until the issues are better understood and the
issues with the lazy allocation patches are resolved.
2004-01-17 21:54:04 +00:00
Warner Losh
e4b59fc500 Add support for subtractive decoding bridges. These bridges pass all
signals to addresses to the child busses.  Typically, ProgIf of 1
means a subtractive bridge.  However, Intel has a whole lot of ones
with a ProgIf of 80 that are also subtractive.  We cope with these
bridges too.  This eliminates hw.pci.allow_unsupported_io_range
because that had almost the same effect as these patches (almost means
'buggy').  Remove the bogus checks for ISA bus locations: these cycles
aren't special and are only passed by transparent bridges.

We allow any range to succeed.  If the range is a superset of the
range that's decoded, trim the resource to that range.  Otherwise,
pass the range unchanged.  This will change the location that PC Card
and CardBus cards are attached.  This might bogusly cause some
overlapping allocation that wasn't present before, but the overlapping
fixes need to be in the pci level.

There's also a few formatting changes here.
2004-01-11 06:52:31 +00:00
Mike Silbersack
184dcdc7c8 Change all SYSCTLS which are readonly and have a related TUNABLE
from CTLFLAG_RD to CTLFLAG_RDTUN so that sysctl(8) can provide
more useful error messages.
2003-10-21 18:28:36 +00:00
David E. O'Brien
aad970f1fe Use __FBSDID().
Also some minor style cleanups.
2003-08-24 17:55:58 +00:00
Warner Losh
38d8c9940b Prefer new location of pci include files (which have only been in the
tree for two or more years now), except in a few places where there's
code to be compatible with older versions of FreeBSD.
2003-08-22 06:42:59 +00:00
Warner Losh
b0cb115fb7 Prefer the uintXX_t to the u_intXX_t names. 2003-08-22 03:11:53 +00:00
Bernd Walter
cdc95e1bb8 Calculate routed interrupts using the slot number from the device and
not that of the bridge.

Approved by:	re (jhb)
2003-05-22 17:45:26 +00:00
Benno Rice
2c2d1d071e Make the base pcib_route_interrupt method available to other pci-pci bridge
sub-classes.

This allows the powerpc kernel to build again.

Forgotten by:	benno
Spotted by:	grehan
2003-01-14 11:37:56 +00:00
Warner Losh
a8b354a809 Properly account for prefetchable memory when a request is being made.
We allow the request to go through if it matches either a prefetchable
or a non-prefetchable part of the bridge.  We do not check to make
sure it is the right kind of memory because most drivers to not yet
properly set RF_PREFETCHABLE (only cardbus seems to do so, and I'm not
entirely sure it does it right).  RF_PREFETCHABLE was invented for
cardbus, so hasn't been properly documented yet.

This is still overridable by hw.pci.allow_unsupported_io_ranges, but
the need for that is greatly reduced, especially for the nvida driver.

Approved by: re
Reviewed by: jhb and many testers
Submitted by: Matt Emmerton (although this has been reworked somewhat)
2002-12-03 08:34:20 +00:00
John Baldwin
1bbf246462 Fix a couple of bugs in host_pcib_get_busno():
- If a PCI device is not present, then a 32-bit read_config() is going to
  return 0xffffffff not 0xffff.
- For the 82454NX chipset, the MIOC that we read the bus numbers of the
  various host-PCI bridges from is at function (slot) 0x10 not 0x0.

Approved by:	re (rwatson)
2002-11-25 21:53:14 +00:00
John Baldwin
b173edafc7 Add a function host_pcib_get_bnsno() that attempts to determine the bus
number of the child bus of a host to PCI bridge by reading from proprietary
configuration registers in the host to PCI bridge devices.

Approved by:	re
2002-11-22 17:50:47 +00:00
Maxime Henrion
d541eb80c6 Unbreak kernel build.
Submitted by:	Hiten Pandya <hiten@angelica.unixdaemons.com>
2002-11-13 17:34:12 +00:00
Matthew N. Dodd
1c54ff3315 Convert kernel compile option PCI_ALLOW_UNSUPPORTED_IO_RANGE to
a loader tunable hw.pci.allow_unsupported_io_range.

Submitted by:	 Hiten Pandya <hiten@angelica.unixdaemons.com>
Approved by:	 re (murray)
2002-11-13 09:42:25 +00:00
John Baldwin
38906aed9a Export pcib_attach() as a "protected" for use in subclasses of the PCI-PCI
bridge driver.
2002-09-06 22:14:00 +00:00
John Baldwin
cea0a89545 Prefer the physical bus number of the PCI bus as the unit of the pciX
device created.
2002-09-06 16:09:07 +00:00
John Baldwin
c6a121ab5e Make the printf messages when routing interrupts more consistent in the
various PCI bridge drivers.
2002-09-05 17:08:35 +00:00
John Baldwin
6f0d58848f Export a few symbols as globals to allow subclassing of this driver. In
OOP speak, you would mark these as 'protected' members.  Specifically:
- Make the pcib_softc struct public so it can be used by subclasses.
- Make pcib_{read,write}_ivar(), pcib_alloc_resource(), pcib_maxslots(),
  and pcib_{read,write}_config() globals that can be used by subclasses.
- Make the pcib devclass a global variable.
- Move most of the pcib_attach() function into a global
  pcib_attach_common() function that can be called by the attach routines
  of subclasses.

Tested on:	i386, alpha, sparc64, ia64
2002-08-26 15:57:08 +00:00
Warner Losh
8961964d97 Fix an edge case wrt membase, but more changes needed 2002-04-13 05:52:35 +00:00
Warner Losh
1efefb2d4d Fix warnings introduced in the PCI_ALLOW_UNSUPPORTED_IO_RANGE case. 2002-02-26 03:31:35 +00:00
Poul-Henning Kamp
6e47a4f646 Allow PCI_ALLOW_UNSUPPORTED_IO_RANGE to leave broken setups broken enough
to work.
2002-02-22 11:21:02 +00:00