Commit Graph

83 Commits

Author SHA1 Message Date
Matthew Dillon
936524aa02 Implement a low-memory deadlock solution.
Removed most of the hacks that were trying to deal with low-memory
    situations prior to now.

    The new code is based on the concept that I/O must be able to function in
    a low memory situation.  All major modules related to I/O (except
    networking) have been adjusted to allow allocation out of the system
    reserve memory pool.  These modules now detect a low memory situation but
    rather then block they instead continue to operate, then return resources
    to the memory pool instead of cache them or leave them wired.

    Code has been added to stall in a low-memory situation prior to a vnode
    being locked.

    Thus situations where a process blocks in a low-memory condition while
    holding a locked vnode have been reduced to near nothing.  Not only will
    I/O continue to operate, but many prior deadlock conditions simply no
    longer exist.

Implement a number of VFS/BIO fixes

	(found by Ian): in biodone(), bogus-page replacement code, the loop
        was not properly incrementing loop variables prior to a continue
        statement.  We do not believe this code can be hit anyway but we
        aren't taking any chances.  We'll turn the whole section into a
        panic (as it already is in brelse()) after the release is rolled.

	In biodone(), the foff calculation was incorrectly
        clamped to the iosize, causing the wrong foff to be calculated
        for pages in the case of an I/O error or biodone() called without
        initiating I/O.  The problem always caused a panic before.  Now it
        doesn't.  The problem is mainly an issue with NFS.

	Fixed casts for ~PAGE_MASK.  This code worked properly before only
        because the calculations use signed arithmatic.  Better to properly
        extend PAGE_MASK first before inverting it for the 64 bit masking
        op.

	In brelse(), the bogus_page fixup code was improperly throwing
        away the original contents of 'm' when it did the j-loop to
        fix the bogus pages.  The result was that it would potentially
        invalidate parts of the *WRONG* page(!), leading to corruption.

	There may still be cases where a background bitmap write is
        being duplicated, causing potential corruption.  We have identified
        a potentially serious bug related to this but the fix is still TBD.
        So instead this patch contains a KASSERT to detect the problem
  	and panic the machine rather then continue to corrupt the filesystem.
	The problem does not occur very often..  it is very hard to
	reproduce, and it may or may not be the cause of the corruption
	people have reported.

Review by: (VFS/BIO: mckusick, Ian Dowse <iedowse@maths.tcd.ie>)
Testing by: (VM/Deadlock) Paul Saab <ps@yahoo-inc.com>
2000-11-18 23:06:26 +00:00
David E. O'Brien
ee2fd03885 Make the arguments match the functionality of the functions. 2000-08-26 04:51:39 +00:00
Alfred Perlstein
4c8545c13d #elsif -> #elif
Noticed by: green
2000-07-11 09:41:29 +00:00
John Baldwin
9a20f99adf Replace the PQ_*CACHE options with a single PQ_CACHESIZE option that you
set equal to the number of kilobytes in your cache.  The old options are
still supported for backwards compatibility.

Submitted by:	Kelly Yancey <kbyanc@posi.net>
2000-07-04 08:55:18 +00:00
Matthew Dillon
8b03c8ed5e This is a cleanup patch to Peter's new OBJT_PHYS VM object type
and sysv shared memory support for it.  It implements a new
    PG_UNMANAGED flag that has slightly different characteristics
    from PG_FICTICIOUS.

    A new sysctl, kern.ipc.shm_use_phys has been added to enable the
    use of physically-backed sysv shared memory rather then swap-backed.
    Physically backed shm segments are not tracked with PV entries,
    allowing programs which use a large shm segment as a rendezvous
    point to operate without eating an insane amount of KVM in the
    PV entry management.  Read: Oracle.

    Peter's OBJT_PHYS object will also allow us to eventually implement
    page-table sharing and/or 4MB physical page support for such segments.
    We're half way there.
2000-05-29 22:40:54 +00:00
Jake Burkholder
e39756439c Back out the previous change to the queue(3) interface.
It was not discussed and should probably not happen.

Requested by:		msmith and others
2000-05-26 02:09:24 +00:00
Jake Burkholder
740a1973a6 Change the way that the queue(3) structures are declared; don't assume that
the type argument to *_HEAD and *_ENTRY is a struct.

Suggested by:	phk
Reviewed by:	phk
Approved by:	mdodd
2000-05-23 20:41:01 +00:00
Peter Wemm
0385347c1a Implement an optimization of the VM<->pmap API. Pass vm_page_t's directly
to various pmap_*() functions instead of looking up the physical address
and passing that.  In many cases, the first thing the pmap code was doing
was going to a lot of trouble to get back the original vm_page_t, or
it's shadow pv_table entry.

Inspired by: John Dyson's 1998 patches.

Also:
Eliminate pv_table as a seperate thing and build it into a machine
dependent part of vm_page_t.  This eliminates having a seperate set of
structions that shadow each other in a 1:1 fashion that we often went to
a lot of trouble to translate from one to the other. (see above)
This happens to save 4 bytes of physical memory for each page in the
system.  (8 bytes on the Alpha).

Eliminate the use of the phys_avail[] array to determine if a page is
managed (ie: it has pv_entries etc).  Store this information in a flag.
Things like device_pager set it because they create vm_page_t's on the
fly that do not have pv_entries.  This makes it easier to "unmanage" a
page of physical memory (this will be taken advantage of in subsequent
commits).

Add a function to add a new page to the freelist.  This could be used
for reclaiming the previously wasted pages left over from preloaded
loader(8) files.

Reviewed by:	dillon
2000-05-21 12:50:18 +00:00
Peter Wemm
c447342094 Change #ifdef KERNEL to #ifdef _KERNEL in the public headers. "KERNEL"
is an application space macro and the applications are supposed to be free
to use it as they please (but cannot).  This is consistant with the other
BSD's who made this change quite some time ago.  More commits to come.
1999-12-29 05:07:58 +00:00
Matthew Dillon
4f79d873c1 Add MAP_NOSYNC feature to mmap(), and MADV_NOSYNC and MADV_AUTOSYNC to
madvise().

    This feature prevents the update daemon from gratuitously flushing
    dirty pages associated with a mapped file-backed region of memory.  The
    system pager will still page the memory as necessary and the VM system
    will still be fully coherent with the filesystem.  Modifications made
    by other means to the same area of memory, for example by write(), are
    unaffected.  The feature works on a page-granularity basis.

    MAP_NOSYNC allows one to use mmap() to share memory between processes
    without incuring any significant filesystem overhead, putting it in
    the same performance category as SysV Shared memory and anonymous memory.

Reviewed by: julian, alc, dg
1999-12-12 03:19:33 +00:00
Alan Cox
be72f78813 The core of this patch is to vm/vm_page.h. The effects are two-fold: (1) to
eliminate an extra (useless) level of indirection in half of the page
queue accesses and (2) to use a single name for each queue throughout,
instead of, e.g., "vm_page_queue_active" in some places and
"vm_page_queues[PQ_ACTIVE]" in others.

Reviewed by:	dillon
1999-10-30 07:37:14 +00:00
Matthew Dillon
90ecac61c0 Reviewed by: Alan Cox <alc@cs.rice.edu>, David Greenman <dg@root.com>
Replace various VM related page count calculations strewn over the
    VM code with inlines to aid in readability and to reduce fragility
    in the code where modules depend on the same test being performed
    to properly sleep and wakeup.

    Split out a portion of the page deactivation code into an inline
    in vm_page.c to support vm_page_dontneed().

    add vm_page_dontneed(), which handles the madvise MADV_DONTNEED
    feature in a related commit coming up for vm_map.c/vm_object.c.  This
    code prevents degenerate cases where an essentially active page may
    be rotated through a subset of the paging lists, resulting in premature
    disposal.
1999-09-17 04:56:40 +00:00
Peter Wemm
c3aac50f28 $Id$ -> $FreeBSD$ 1999-08-28 01:08:13 +00:00
Brian Feldman
38c808edb7 Unbreak the nfs KLD_MODULE. It needs a bit more of vm_page.h than was
exported (notably vm_page_undirty()). Also, let vm_page_dirty() work
in a KLD.
1999-08-17 22:48:10 +00:00
Alan Cox
2c28a10540 Add the (inline) function vm_page_undirty for clearing the dirty bitmask
of a vm_page.

Use it.

Submitted by:	dillon
1999-08-17 04:02:34 +00:00
Alan Cox
175d1f69bf contigmalloc1 (currently) depends on PQ_FREE and PQ_CACHE not being 0
to tell a valid "struct vm_page" from an invalid one in the vm_page_array.
This isn't a very robust method.
1999-08-15 05:36:43 +00:00
Matt Jacob
3739d7da89 Add back in old definitions if we're compiling for alpha. 1999-08-15 01:16:53 +00:00
Alan Cox
514bfcc440 Don't create a "struct vpgqueues" for PQ_NONE. 1999-08-14 06:25:54 +00:00
Alan Cox
1aefb1d957 Make the default page coloring parameters match a (non-Xeon) Pentium II/III.
This setting is also acceptable for Celerons and Pentium Pros
with less than 1MB L2 caches.

Note: PQ_L2_SIZE is a misnomer.  The correct number of colors is
a function of the cache's degree of associativity as well as its size.

Submitted by:	bde and alc
1999-08-12 21:16:53 +00:00
Alan Cox
5d2aec8927 Change the type of vpgqueues::lcnt from "int *" to "int". The indirection
served no purpose.
1999-07-31 18:31:00 +00:00
Alan Cox
3b21348301 Reduce the number of "magic constants" used for page coloring
by one: PQ_PRIME2 and PQ_PRIME3 are used to accomplish the same
thing at different places in the kernel.  Drop PQ_PRIME3.
1999-07-22 06:04:17 +00:00
Alan Cox
9c89c228fe Remove (1) "extern" declarations for variables that were previously
made "static" and (2) initialized but unused variables.
1999-06-22 07:18:20 +00:00
Alan Cox
6ea5bd80fe Remove some unused function and variable declarations. 1999-06-19 18:42:53 +00:00
Alan Cox
4221e284a3 The VFS/BIO subsystem contained a number of hacks in order to optimize
piecemeal, middle-of-file writes for NFS.  These hacks have caused no
end of trouble, especially when combined with mmap().  I've removed
them.  Instead, NFS will issue a read-before-write to fully
instantiate the struct buf containing the write.  NFS does, however,
optimize piecemeal appends to files.  For most common file operations,
you will not notice the difference.  The sole remaining fragment in
the VFS/BIO system is b_dirtyoff/end, which NFS uses to avoid cache
coherency issues with read-merge-write style operations.  NFS also
optimizes the write-covers-entire-buffer case by avoiding the
read-before-write.  There is quite a bit of room for further
optimization in these areas.

The VM system marks pages fully-valid (AKA vm_page_t->valid =
VM_PAGE_BITS_ALL) in several places, most noteably in vm_fault.  This
is not correct operation.  The vm_pager_get_pages() code is now
responsible for marking VM pages all-valid.  A number of VM helper
routines have been added to aid in zeroing-out the invalid portions of
a VM page prior to the page being marked all-valid.  This operation is
necessary to properly support mmap().  The zeroing occurs most often
when dealing with file-EOF situations.  Several bugs have been fixed
in the NFS subsystem, including bits handling file and directory EOF
situations and buf->b_flags consistancy issues relating to clearing
B_ERROR & B_INVAL, and handling B_DONE.

getblk() and allocbuf() have been rewritten.  B_CACHE operation is now
formally defined in comments and more straightforward in
implementation.  B_CACHE for VMIO buffers is based on the validity of
the backing store.  B_CACHE for non-VMIO buffers is based simply on
whether the buffer is B_INVAL or not (B_CACHE set if B_INVAL clear,
and vise-versa).  biodone() is now responsible for setting B_CACHE
when a successful read completes.  B_CACHE is also set when a bdwrite()
is initiated and when a bwrite() is initiated.  VFS VOP_BWRITE
routines (there are only two - nfs_bwrite() and bwrite()) are now
expected to set B_CACHE.  This means that bowrite() and bawrite() also
set B_CACHE indirectly.

There are a number of places in the code which were previously using
buf->b_bufsize (which is DEV_BSIZE aligned) when they should have
been using buf->b_bcount.  These have been fixed.  getblk() now clears
B_DONE on return because the rest of the system is so bad about
dealing with B_DONE.

Major fixes to NFS/TCP have been made.  A server-side bug could cause
requests to be lost by the server due to nfs_realign() overwriting
other rpc's in the same TCP mbuf chain.  The server's kernel must be
recompiled to get the benefit of the fixes.

Submitted by:	Matthew Dillon <dillon@apollo.backplane.com>
1999-05-02 23:57:16 +00:00
Julian Elischer
8d17e69460 Catch a case spotted by Tor where files mmapped could leave garbage in the
unallocated parts of the last page when the file ended on a frag
but not a page boundary.
Delimitted by tags PRE_MATT_MMAP_EOF and POST_MATT_MMAP_EOF,
in files alpha/alpha/pmap.c i386/i386/pmap.c nfs/nfs_bio.c vm/pmap.h
    vm/vm_page.c vm/vm_page.h vm/vnode_pager.c miscfs/specfs/spec_vnops.c
    ufs/ufs/ufs_readwrite.c kern/vfs_bio.c

Submitted by: Matt Dillon <dillon@freebsd.org>
Reviewed by: Alan Cox <alc@freebsd.org>
1999-04-05 19:38:30 +00:00
Julian Elischer
811c2e1a76 Fix breakage in last commit
Submitted by: Brian Feldman <green@unixhelp.org>
1999-03-15 05:09:48 +00:00
Julian Elischer
0237469f43 A bit of a hack, but allows the vn device to be a module again.
Submitted by: Matt Dillon <dillon@freebsd.org>
1999-03-14 20:40:15 +00:00
Matthew Dillon
efcae3d355 Minor reorganization of vm_page_alloc(). No functional changes have
been made but the code has been reorganized and documented to make
    it more readable, reduce the size of the code, and optimize the branch
    path caching capabilities that most modern processors have.
1999-02-15 06:52:14 +00:00
Matthew Dillon
faa273d5c2 Rip out PQ_ZERO queue. PQ_ZERO functionality is now combined in with
PQ_FREE.  There is little operational difference other then the kernel
    being a few kilobytes smaller and the code being more readable.

    * vm_page_select_free() has been *greatly* simplified.
    * The PQ_ZERO page queue and supporting structures have been removed
    * vm_page_zero_idle() revamped (see below)

    PG_ZERO setting and clearing has been migrated from vm_page_alloc()
    to vm_page_free[_zero]() and will eventually be guarenteed to remain
    tracked throughout a page's life ( if it isn't already ).

    When a page is freed, PG_ZERO pages are appended to the appropriate
    tailq in the PQ_FREE queue while non-PG_ZERO pages are prepended.
    When locating a new free page, PG_ZERO selection operates from within
    vm_page_list_find() ( get page from end of queue instead of beginning
    of queue ) and then only occurs in the nominal critical path case.  If
    the nominal case misses, both normal and zero-page allocation devolves
    into the same _vm_page_list_find() select code without any specific
    zero-page optimizations.

    Additionally, vm_page_zero_idle() has been revamped.  Hysteresis has been
    added and zero-page tracking adjusted to conform with the other changes.
    Currently hysteresis is set at 1/3 (lo) and 1/2 (hi) the number of free
    pages.  We may wish to increase both parameters as time permits.  The
    hysteresis is designed to avoid silly zeroing in borderline allocation/free
    situations.
1999-02-08 00:37:36 +00:00
Matthew Dillon
a0e7b3e5ce Remove L1 cache coloring optimization ( leave L2 cache coloring opt ).
Rewrite vm_page_list_find() and vm_page_select_free() - make inline out
    of nominal case.
1999-02-07 20:45:15 +00:00
Matthew Dillon
161a8f6519 Add vm_page_dirty() inline with PQ_CACHE sanity check 1999-01-24 05:57:50 +00:00
Matthew Dillon
a7039a1d42 Add invariants to vm_page_busy() and vm_page_wakeup() to check for
PG_BUSY stupidity.
1999-01-24 01:05:15 +00:00
Matthew Dillon
41dbefba28 The TAILQ hashq has been turned into a singly-linked=list link,
reducing the size of vm_page_t.

    SWAPBLK_NONE and SWAPBLK_MASK are defined here.  These actually are
    more generalized then their names imply, but their placement is somewhat
    of a legacy issue from a prior test version of this code that put
    the swapblk in the vm_page_t structure.  That test code was eventually
    thrown away.  The legacy remains.

    Added vm_page_flash() inline.  Similar to vm_page_wakeup() except that
    it does not clear PG_BUSY ( one assumes that PG_BUSY is already clear ).
    Used by a number of routines to wakeup waiters.

    Collapsed some of the code in inline calls to make other inline calls.
    GCC will optimize this well and it reduces duplication.

    vm_page_free() and vm_page_free_zero() inlines added to convert to
    the proper vm_page_free_toq() call.

    vm_page_sleep_busy() inline added, replacing vm_page_sleep() ( which has
    been removed ).  This implements a much more optimizable page-waiting
    function.
1999-01-21 10:06:24 +00:00
Matthew Dillon
1c7c3c6a86 This is a rather large commit that encompasses the new swapper,
changes to the VM system to support the new swapper, VM bug
    fixes, several VM optimizations, and some additional revamping of the
    VM code.  The specific bug fixes will be documented with additional
    forced commits.  This commit is somewhat rough in regards to code
    cleanup issues.

Reviewed by:	"John S. Dyson" <root@dyson.iquest.net>, "David Greenman" <dg@root.com>
1999-01-21 08:29:12 +00:00
Eivind Eklund
5526d2d920 Split DIAGNOSTIC -> DIAGNOSTIC, INVARIANTS, and INVARIANT_SUPPORT as
discussed on -hackers.

Introduce 'KASSERT(assertion, ("panic message", args))' for simple
check + panic.

Reviewed by:	msmith
1999-01-08 17:31:30 +00:00
David Greenman
730075613a Added a second argument, "activate" to the vm_page_unwire() call so that
the caller can select either inactive or active queue to put the page on.
1998-10-28 13:37:02 +00:00
David Greenman
300ee8246e Nuked PG_TABLED flag. Replaced with m->object != NULL. 1998-10-21 14:46:42 +00:00
Doug Rabson
e69763a315 Cosmetic changes to the PAGE_XXX macros to make them consistent with
the other objects in vm.
1998-09-04 08:06:57 +00:00
Garrett Wollman
85e7f5492b Separate wakeup conditions for page I/O count (pg_busy) and lock (PG_BUSY).
This is not sa completely solution to the deadlock, but the additional wakeups
have helped in my observation.

Suggested by: John Dyson
1998-09-01 17:12:19 +00:00
Doug Rabson
069e9bc1b4 Change various syscalls to use size_t arguments instead of u_int.
Add some overflow checks to read/write (from bde).

Change all modifications to vm_page::flags, vm_page::busy, vm_object::flags
and vm_object::paging_in_progress to use operations which are not
interruptable.

Reviewed by: Bruce Evans <bde@zeta.org.au>
1998-08-24 08:39:39 +00:00
Stephen McKay
9e80236560 Correct/clarify some comments. 1998-08-22 15:24:09 +00:00
John-Mark Gurney
20f718132d document some VM paging options for cache sizes:
PQ_NOOPT	no coloring
PQ_LARGECACHE	used for 512k/16k cache
PQ_HUGECACHE	used for 1024k/16k cache
1998-06-30 08:01:30 +00:00
Bruce Evans
be160d60ab Removed unused includes. 1998-06-21 18:02:50 +00:00
Doug Rabson
ecbb00a262 This commit fixes various 64bit portability problems required for
FreeBSD/alpha.  The most significant item is to change the command
argument to ioctl functions from int to u_long.  This change brings us
inline with various other BSD versions.  Driver writers may like to
use (__FreeBSD_version == 300003) to detect this change.

The prototype FreeBSD/alpha machdep will follow in a couple of days
time.
1998-06-07 17:13:14 +00:00
John Dyson
b9cefc08e2 Support a 16K first level cache for 512K 2nd level. Also, add support
for 1MB 2nd level cache.
1998-05-24 04:25:27 +00:00
John Dyson
8f9110f6a1 This mega-commit is meant to fix numerous interrelated problems. There
has been some bitrot and incorrect assumptions in the vfs_bio code.  These
problems have manifest themselves worse on NFS type filesystems, but can
still affect local filesystems under certain circumstances.  Most of
the problems have involved mmap consistancy, and as a side-effect broke
the vfs.ioopt code.  This code might have been committed seperately, but
almost everything is interrelated.

1)	Allow (pmap_object_init_pt) prefaulting of buffer-busy pages that
	are fully valid.
2)	Rather than deactivating erroneously read initial (header) pages in
	kern_exec, we now free them.
3)	Fix the rundown of non-VMIO buffers that are in an inconsistent
	(missing vp) state.
4)	Fix the disassociation of pages from buffers in brelse.  The previous
	code had rotted and was faulty in a couple of important circumstances.
5)	Remove a gratuitious buffer wakeup in vfs_vmio_release.
6)	Remove a crufty and currently unused cluster mechanism for VBLK
	files in vfs_bio_awrite.  When the code is functional, I'll add back
	a cleaner version.
7)	The page busy count wakeups assocated with the buffer cache usage were
	incorrectly cleaned up in a previous commit by me.  Revert to the
	original, correct version, but with a cleaner implementation.
8)	The cluster read code now tries to keep data associated with buffers
	more aggressively (without breaking the heuristics) when it is presumed
	that the read data (buffers) will be soon needed.
9)	Change to filesystem lockmgr locks so that they use LK_NOPAUSE.  The
	delay loop waiting is not useful for filesystem locks, due to the
	length of the time intervals.
10)	Correct and clean-up spec_getpages.
11)	Implement a fully functional nfs_getpages, nfs_putpages.
12)	Fix nfs_write so that modifications are coherent with the NFS data on
	the server disk (at least as well as NFS seems to allow.)
13)	Properly support MS_INVALIDATE on NFS.
14)	Properly pass down MS_INVALIDATE to lower levels of the VM code from
	vm_map_clean.
15)	Better support the notion of pages being busy but valid, so that
	fewer in-transit waits occur.  (use p->busy more for pageouts instead
	of PG_BUSY.)  Since the page is fully valid, it is still usable for
	reads.
16)	It is possible (in error) for cached pages to be busy.  Make the
	page allocation code handle that case correctly.  (It should probably
	be a printf or panic, but I want the system to handle coding errors
	robustly.  I'll probably add a printf.)
17)	Correct the design and usage of vm_page_sleep.  It didn't handle
	consistancy problems very well, so make the design a little less
	lofty.  After vm_page_sleep, if it ever blocked, it is still important
	to relookup the page (if the object generation count changed), and
	verify it's status (always.)
18)	In vm_pageout.c, vm_pageout_clean had rotted, so clean that up.
19)	Push the page busy for writes and VM_PROT_READ into vm_pageout_flush.
20)	Fix vm_pager_put_pages and it's descendents to support an int flag
	instead of a boolean, so that we can pass down the invalidate bit.
1998-03-07 21:37:31 +00:00
John Dyson
ffc82b0a70 1) Use a more consistent page wait methodology.
2)	Do not unnecessarily force page blocking when paging
	pages out.
3)	Further improve swap pager performance and correctness,
	including fixing the paging in progress deadlock (except
	in severe I/O error conditions.)
4)	Enable vfs_ioopt=1 as a default.
5)	Fix and enable the page prezeroing in SMP mode.

All in all, SMP systems especially should show a significant
improvement in "snappyness."
1998-03-01 04:18:54 +00:00
John Dyson
95461b450d 1) Start using a cleaner and more consistant page allocator instead
of the various ad-hoc schemes.
2)	When bringing in UPAGES, the pmap code needs to do another vm_page_lookup.
3)	When appropriate, set the PG_A or PG_M bits a-priori to both avoid some
	processor errata, and to minimize redundant processor updating of page
	tables.
4)	Modify pmap_protect so that it can only remove permissions (as it
	originally supported.)  The additional capability is not needed.
5)	Streamline read-only to read-write page mappings.
6)	For pmap_copy_page, don't enable write mapping for source page.
7)	Correct and clean-up pmap_incore.
8)	Cluster initial kern_exec pagin.
9)	Removal of some minor lint from kern_malloc.
10)	Correct some ioopt code.
11)	Remove some dead code from the MI swapout routine.
12)	Correct vm_object_deallocate (to remove backing_object ref.)
13)	Fix dead object handling, that had problems under heavy memory load.
14)	Add minor vm_page_lookup improvements.
15)	Some pages are not in objects, and make sure that the vm_page.c can
	properly support such pages.
16)	Add some more page deficit handling.
17)	Some minor code readability improvements.
1998-02-05 03:32:49 +00:00
Peter Wemm
6875d25465 Back out part 1 of the MCFH that changed $Id$ to $FreeBSD$. We are not
ready for it yet.
1997-02-22 09:48:43 +00:00
Jordan K. Hubbard
1130b656e5 Make the long-awaited change from $Id$ to $FreeBSD$
This will make a number of things easier in the future, as well as (finally!)
avoiding the Id-smashing problem which has plagued developers for so long.

Boy, I'm glad we're not using sup anymore.  This update would have been
insane otherwise.
1997-01-14 07:20:47 +00:00