freebsd-dev/module/zfs/zfs_rlock.c
Brian Behlendorf 450dc149bd Range lock performance improvements
The original range lock implementation had to be modified by commit
8926ab7 because it was unsafe on Linux.  In particular, calling
cv_destroy() immediately after cv_broadcast() is dangerous because
the waiters may still be asleep.  Thus the following cv_destroy()
will free memory which may still be in use.

This was fixed by updating cv_destroy() to block on waiters but
this in turn introduced a deadlock.  The deadlock was resolved
with the use of a taskq to move the offending free outside the
range lock.  This worked well but using the taskq for the free
resulted in a serious performace hit.  This is somewhat ironic
because at the time I felt using the taskq might improve things
by making the free asynchronous.

This patch refines the original fix and moves the free from the
taskq to a private free list.  Then items which must be free'd
are simply inserted in to the list.  When the range lock is dropped
it's safe to free the items.  The list is walked and all rl_t
entries are freed.

This change improves small cached read performance by 26x.  This
was expected because for small reads the number of locking calls
goes up significantly.  More surprisingly this change significantly
improves large cache read performance.  This probably attributable
to better cpu/memory locality.  Very likely the same processor
which allocated the memory is now freeing it.

bs	ext3	zfs	zfs+fix		faster
----------------------------------------------
512     435     3       79      	26x
1k      820     7       160     	22x
2k      1536    14      305     	21x
4k      2764    28      572     	20x
8k      3788    50      1024    	20x
16k     4300    86      1843    	21x
32k     4505    138     2560    	18x
64k     5324    252     3891    	15x
128k    5427    276     4710    	17x
256k    5427    413     5017    	12x
512k    5427    497     5324    	10x
1m      5427    521     5632    	10x

Closes #142
2011-03-08 12:44:06 -08:00

625 lines
17 KiB
C

/*
* CDDL HEADER START
*
* The contents of this file are subject to the terms of the
* Common Development and Distribution License (the "License").
* You may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
*
* You can obtain a copy of the license at usr/src/OPENSOLARIS.LICENSE
* or http://www.opensolaris.org/os/licensing.
* See the License for the specific language governing permissions
* and limitations under the License.
*
* When distributing Covered Code, include this CDDL HEADER in each
* file and include the License file at usr/src/OPENSOLARIS.LICENSE.
* If applicable, add the following below this CDDL HEADER, with the
* fields enclosed by brackets "[]" replaced with your own identifying
* information: Portions Copyright [yyyy] [name of copyright owner]
*
* CDDL HEADER END
*/
/*
* Copyright 2010 Sun Microsystems, Inc. All rights reserved.
* Use is subject to license terms.
*/
/*
* This file contains the code to implement file range locking in
* ZFS, although there isn't much specific to ZFS (all that comes to mind
* support for growing the blocksize).
*
* Interface
* ---------
* Defined in zfs_rlock.h but essentially:
* rl = zfs_range_lock(zp, off, len, lock_type);
* zfs_range_unlock(rl);
* zfs_range_reduce(rl, off, len);
*
* AVL tree
* --------
* An AVL tree is used to maintain the state of the existing ranges
* that are locked for exclusive (writer) or shared (reader) use.
* The starting range offset is used for searching and sorting the tree.
*
* Common case
* -----------
* The (hopefully) usual case is of no overlaps or contention for
* locks. On entry to zfs_lock_range() a rl_t is allocated; the tree
* searched that finds no overlap, and *this* rl_t is placed in the tree.
*
* Overlaps/Reference counting/Proxy locks
* ---------------------------------------
* The avl code only allows one node at a particular offset. Also it's very
* inefficient to search through all previous entries looking for overlaps
* (because the very 1st in the ordered list might be at offset 0 but
* cover the whole file).
* So this implementation uses reference counts and proxy range locks.
* Firstly, only reader locks use reference counts and proxy locks,
* because writer locks are exclusive.
* When a reader lock overlaps with another then a proxy lock is created
* for that range and replaces the original lock. If the overlap
* is exact then the reference count of the proxy is simply incremented.
* Otherwise, the proxy lock is split into smaller lock ranges and
* new proxy locks created for non overlapping ranges.
* The reference counts are adjusted accordingly.
* Meanwhile, the orginal lock is kept around (this is the callers handle)
* and its offset and length are used when releasing the lock.
*
* Thread coordination
* -------------------
* In order to make wakeups efficient and to ensure multiple continuous
* readers on a range don't starve a writer for the same range lock,
* two condition variables are allocated in each rl_t.
* If a writer (or reader) can't get a range it initialises the writer
* (or reader) cv; sets a flag saying there's a writer (or reader) waiting;
* and waits on that cv. When a thread unlocks that range it wakes up all
* writers then all readers before destroying the lock.
*
* Append mode writes
* ------------------
* Append mode writes need to lock a range at the end of a file.
* The offset of the end of the file is determined under the
* range locking mutex, and the lock type converted from RL_APPEND to
* RL_WRITER and the range locked.
*
* Grow block handling
* -------------------
* ZFS supports multiple block sizes currently upto 128K. The smallest
* block size is used for the file which is grown as needed. During this
* growth all other writers and readers must be excluded.
* So if the block size needs to be grown then the whole file is
* exclusively locked, then later the caller will reduce the lock
* range to just the range to be written using zfs_reduce_range.
*/
#include <sys/zfs_rlock.h>
/*
* Check if a write lock can be grabbed, or wait and recheck until available.
*/
static void
zfs_range_lock_writer(znode_t *zp, rl_t *new)
{
avl_tree_t *tree = &zp->z_range_avl;
rl_t *rl;
avl_index_t where;
uint64_t end_size;
uint64_t off = new->r_off;
uint64_t len = new->r_len;
for (;;) {
/*
* Range locking is also used by zvol and uses a
* dummied up znode. However, for zvol, we don't need to
* append or grow blocksize, and besides we don't have
* a "sa" data or zfs_sb_t - so skip that processing.
*
* Yes, this is ugly, and would be solved by not handling
* grow or append in range lock code. If that was done then
* we could make the range locking code generically available
* to other non-zfs consumers.
*/
if (!zp->z_is_zvol) { /* caller is ZPL */
/*
* If in append mode pick up the current end of file.
* This is done under z_range_lock to avoid races.
*/
if (new->r_type == RL_APPEND)
new->r_off = zp->z_size;
/*
* If we need to grow the block size then grab the whole
* file range. This is also done under z_range_lock to
* avoid races.
*/
end_size = MAX(zp->z_size, new->r_off + len);
if (end_size > zp->z_blksz && (!ISP2(zp->z_blksz) ||
zp->z_blksz < ZTOZSB(zp)->z_max_blksz)) {
new->r_off = 0;
new->r_len = UINT64_MAX;
}
}
/*
* First check for the usual case of no locks
*/
if (avl_numnodes(tree) == 0) {
new->r_type = RL_WRITER; /* convert to writer */
avl_add(tree, new);
return;
}
/*
* Look for any locks in the range.
*/
rl = avl_find(tree, new, &where);
if (rl)
goto wait; /* already locked at same offset */
rl = (rl_t *)avl_nearest(tree, where, AVL_AFTER);
if (rl && (rl->r_off < new->r_off + new->r_len))
goto wait;
rl = (rl_t *)avl_nearest(tree, where, AVL_BEFORE);
if (rl && rl->r_off + rl->r_len > new->r_off)
goto wait;
new->r_type = RL_WRITER; /* convert possible RL_APPEND */
avl_insert(tree, new, where);
return;
wait:
if (!rl->r_write_wanted) {
cv_init(&rl->r_wr_cv, NULL, CV_DEFAULT, NULL);
rl->r_write_wanted = B_TRUE;
}
cv_wait(&rl->r_wr_cv, &zp->z_range_lock);
/* reset to original */
new->r_off = off;
new->r_len = len;
}
}
/*
* If this is an original (non-proxy) lock then replace it by
* a proxy and return the proxy.
*/
static rl_t *
zfs_range_proxify(avl_tree_t *tree, rl_t *rl)
{
rl_t *proxy;
if (rl->r_proxy)
return (rl); /* already a proxy */
ASSERT3U(rl->r_cnt, ==, 1);
ASSERT(rl->r_write_wanted == B_FALSE);
ASSERT(rl->r_read_wanted == B_FALSE);
avl_remove(tree, rl);
rl->r_cnt = 0;
/* create a proxy range lock */
proxy = kmem_alloc(sizeof (rl_t), KM_SLEEP);
proxy->r_off = rl->r_off;
proxy->r_len = rl->r_len;
proxy->r_cnt = 1;
proxy->r_type = RL_READER;
proxy->r_proxy = B_TRUE;
proxy->r_write_wanted = B_FALSE;
proxy->r_read_wanted = B_FALSE;
avl_add(tree, proxy);
return (proxy);
}
/*
* Split the range lock at the supplied offset
* returning the *front* proxy.
*/
static rl_t *
zfs_range_split(avl_tree_t *tree, rl_t *rl, uint64_t off)
{
rl_t *front, *rear;
ASSERT3U(rl->r_len, >, 1);
ASSERT3U(off, >, rl->r_off);
ASSERT3U(off, <, rl->r_off + rl->r_len);
ASSERT(rl->r_write_wanted == B_FALSE);
ASSERT(rl->r_read_wanted == B_FALSE);
/* create the rear proxy range lock */
rear = kmem_alloc(sizeof (rl_t), KM_SLEEP);
rear->r_off = off;
rear->r_len = rl->r_off + rl->r_len - off;
rear->r_cnt = rl->r_cnt;
rear->r_type = RL_READER;
rear->r_proxy = B_TRUE;
rear->r_write_wanted = B_FALSE;
rear->r_read_wanted = B_FALSE;
front = zfs_range_proxify(tree, rl);
front->r_len = off - rl->r_off;
avl_insert_here(tree, rear, front, AVL_AFTER);
return (front);
}
/*
* Create and add a new proxy range lock for the supplied range.
*/
static void
zfs_range_new_proxy(avl_tree_t *tree, uint64_t off, uint64_t len)
{
rl_t *rl;
ASSERT(len);
rl = kmem_alloc(sizeof (rl_t), KM_SLEEP);
rl->r_off = off;
rl->r_len = len;
rl->r_cnt = 1;
rl->r_type = RL_READER;
rl->r_proxy = B_TRUE;
rl->r_write_wanted = B_FALSE;
rl->r_read_wanted = B_FALSE;
avl_add(tree, rl);
}
static void
zfs_range_add_reader(avl_tree_t *tree, rl_t *new, rl_t *prev, avl_index_t where)
{
rl_t *next;
uint64_t off = new->r_off;
uint64_t len = new->r_len;
/*
* prev arrives either:
* - pointing to an entry at the same offset
* - pointing to the entry with the closest previous offset whose
* range may overlap with the new range
* - null, if there were no ranges starting before the new one
*/
if (prev) {
if (prev->r_off + prev->r_len <= off) {
prev = NULL;
} else if (prev->r_off != off) {
/*
* convert to proxy if needed then
* split this entry and bump ref count
*/
prev = zfs_range_split(tree, prev, off);
prev = AVL_NEXT(tree, prev); /* move to rear range */
}
}
ASSERT((prev == NULL) || (prev->r_off == off));
if (prev)
next = prev;
else
next = (rl_t *)avl_nearest(tree, where, AVL_AFTER);
if (next == NULL || off + len <= next->r_off) {
/* no overlaps, use the original new rl_t in the tree */
avl_insert(tree, new, where);
return;
}
if (off < next->r_off) {
/* Add a proxy for initial range before the overlap */
zfs_range_new_proxy(tree, off, next->r_off - off);
}
new->r_cnt = 0; /* will use proxies in tree */
/*
* We now search forward through the ranges, until we go past the end
* of the new range. For each entry we make it a proxy if it
* isn't already, then bump its reference count. If there's any
* gaps between the ranges then we create a new proxy range.
*/
for (prev = NULL; next; prev = next, next = AVL_NEXT(tree, next)) {
if (off + len <= next->r_off)
break;
if (prev && prev->r_off + prev->r_len < next->r_off) {
/* there's a gap */
ASSERT3U(next->r_off, >, prev->r_off + prev->r_len);
zfs_range_new_proxy(tree, prev->r_off + prev->r_len,
next->r_off - (prev->r_off + prev->r_len));
}
if (off + len == next->r_off + next->r_len) {
/* exact overlap with end */
next = zfs_range_proxify(tree, next);
next->r_cnt++;
return;
}
if (off + len < next->r_off + next->r_len) {
/* new range ends in the middle of this block */
next = zfs_range_split(tree, next, off + len);
next->r_cnt++;
return;
}
ASSERT3U(off + len, >, next->r_off + next->r_len);
next = zfs_range_proxify(tree, next);
next->r_cnt++;
}
/* Add the remaining end range. */
zfs_range_new_proxy(tree, prev->r_off + prev->r_len,
(off + len) - (prev->r_off + prev->r_len));
}
/*
* Check if a reader lock can be grabbed, or wait and recheck until available.
*/
static void
zfs_range_lock_reader(znode_t *zp, rl_t *new)
{
avl_tree_t *tree = &zp->z_range_avl;
rl_t *prev, *next;
avl_index_t where;
uint64_t off = new->r_off;
uint64_t len = new->r_len;
/*
* Look for any writer locks in the range.
*/
retry:
prev = avl_find(tree, new, &where);
if (prev == NULL)
prev = (rl_t *)avl_nearest(tree, where, AVL_BEFORE);
/*
* Check the previous range for a writer lock overlap.
*/
if (prev && (off < prev->r_off + prev->r_len)) {
if ((prev->r_type == RL_WRITER) || (prev->r_write_wanted)) {
if (!prev->r_read_wanted) {
cv_init(&prev->r_rd_cv, NULL, CV_DEFAULT, NULL);
prev->r_read_wanted = B_TRUE;
}
cv_wait(&prev->r_rd_cv, &zp->z_range_lock);
goto retry;
}
if (off + len < prev->r_off + prev->r_len)
goto got_lock;
}
/*
* Search through the following ranges to see if there's
* write lock any overlap.
*/
if (prev)
next = AVL_NEXT(tree, prev);
else
next = (rl_t *)avl_nearest(tree, where, AVL_AFTER);
for (; next; next = AVL_NEXT(tree, next)) {
if (off + len <= next->r_off)
goto got_lock;
if ((next->r_type == RL_WRITER) || (next->r_write_wanted)) {
if (!next->r_read_wanted) {
cv_init(&next->r_rd_cv, NULL, CV_DEFAULT, NULL);
next->r_read_wanted = B_TRUE;
}
cv_wait(&next->r_rd_cv, &zp->z_range_lock);
goto retry;
}
if (off + len <= next->r_off + next->r_len)
goto got_lock;
}
got_lock:
/*
* Add the read lock, which may involve splitting existing
* locks and bumping ref counts (r_cnt).
*/
zfs_range_add_reader(tree, new, prev, where);
}
/*
* Lock a range (offset, length) as either shared (RL_READER)
* or exclusive (RL_WRITER). Returns the range lock structure
* for later unlocking or reduce range (if entire file
* previously locked as RL_WRITER).
*/
rl_t *
zfs_range_lock(znode_t *zp, uint64_t off, uint64_t len, rl_type_t type)
{
rl_t *new;
ASSERT(type == RL_READER || type == RL_WRITER || type == RL_APPEND);
new = kmem_alloc(sizeof (rl_t), KM_SLEEP);
new->r_zp = zp;
new->r_off = off;
if (len + off < off) /* overflow */
len = UINT64_MAX - off;
new->r_len = len;
new->r_cnt = 1; /* assume it's going to be in the tree */
new->r_type = type;
new->r_proxy = B_FALSE;
new->r_write_wanted = B_FALSE;
new->r_read_wanted = B_FALSE;
mutex_enter(&zp->z_range_lock);
if (type == RL_READER) {
/*
* First check for the usual case of no locks
*/
if (avl_numnodes(&zp->z_range_avl) == 0)
avl_add(&zp->z_range_avl, new);
else
zfs_range_lock_reader(zp, new);
} else
zfs_range_lock_writer(zp, new); /* RL_WRITER or RL_APPEND */
mutex_exit(&zp->z_range_lock);
return (new);
}
static void
zfs_range_free(void *arg)
{
rl_t *rl = arg;
if (rl->r_write_wanted)
cv_destroy(&rl->r_wr_cv);
if (rl->r_read_wanted)
cv_destroy(&rl->r_rd_cv);
kmem_free(rl, sizeof (rl_t));
}
/*
* Unlock a reader lock
*/
static void
zfs_range_unlock_reader(znode_t *zp, rl_t *remove, list_t *free_list)
{
avl_tree_t *tree = &zp->z_range_avl;
rl_t *rl, *next = NULL;
uint64_t len;
/*
* The common case is when the remove entry is in the tree
* (cnt == 1) meaning there's been no other reader locks overlapping
* with this one. Otherwise the remove entry will have been
* removed from the tree and replaced by proxies (one or
* more ranges mapping to the entire range).
*/
if (remove->r_cnt == 1) {
avl_remove(tree, remove);
mutex_exit(&zp->z_range_lock);
if (remove->r_write_wanted)
cv_broadcast(&remove->r_wr_cv);
if (remove->r_read_wanted)
cv_broadcast(&remove->r_rd_cv);
list_insert_tail(free_list, remove);
} else {
ASSERT3U(remove->r_cnt, ==, 0);
ASSERT3U(remove->r_write_wanted, ==, 0);
ASSERT3U(remove->r_read_wanted, ==, 0);
/*
* Find start proxy representing this reader lock,
* then decrement ref count on all proxies
* that make up this range, freeing them as needed.
*/
rl = avl_find(tree, remove, NULL);
ASSERT(rl);
ASSERT(rl->r_cnt);
ASSERT(rl->r_type == RL_READER);
for (len = remove->r_len; len != 0; rl = next) {
len -= rl->r_len;
if (len) {
next = AVL_NEXT(tree, rl);
ASSERT(next);
ASSERT(rl->r_off + rl->r_len == next->r_off);
ASSERT(next->r_cnt);
ASSERT(next->r_type == RL_READER);
}
rl->r_cnt--;
if (rl->r_cnt == 0) {
avl_remove(tree, rl);
if (rl->r_write_wanted)
cv_broadcast(&rl->r_wr_cv);
if (rl->r_read_wanted)
cv_broadcast(&rl->r_rd_cv);
list_insert_tail(free_list, rl);
}
}
mutex_exit(&zp->z_range_lock);
kmem_free(remove, sizeof (rl_t));
}
}
/*
* Unlock range and destroy range lock structure.
*/
void
zfs_range_unlock(rl_t *rl)
{
znode_t *zp = rl->r_zp;
list_t free_list;
rl_t *free_rl;
ASSERT(rl->r_type == RL_WRITER || rl->r_type == RL_READER);
ASSERT(rl->r_cnt == 1 || rl->r_cnt == 0);
ASSERT(!rl->r_proxy);
list_create(&free_list, sizeof(rl_t), offsetof(rl_t, rl_node));
mutex_enter(&zp->z_range_lock);
if (rl->r_type == RL_WRITER) {
/* writer locks can't be shared or split */
avl_remove(&zp->z_range_avl, rl);
mutex_exit(&zp->z_range_lock);
if (rl->r_write_wanted)
cv_broadcast(&rl->r_wr_cv);
if (rl->r_read_wanted)
cv_broadcast(&rl->r_rd_cv);
list_insert_tail(&free_list, rl);
} else {
/*
* lock may be shared, let zfs_range_unlock_reader()
* release the zp->z_range_lock lock and free the rl_t
*/
zfs_range_unlock_reader(zp, rl, &free_list);
}
while ((free_rl = list_head(&free_list)) != NULL) {
list_remove(&free_list, free_rl);
zfs_range_free(free_rl);
}
list_destroy(&free_list);
}
/*
* Reduce range locked as RL_WRITER from whole file to specified range.
* Asserts the whole file is exclusivly locked and so there's only one
* entry in the tree.
*/
void
zfs_range_reduce(rl_t *rl, uint64_t off, uint64_t len)
{
znode_t *zp = rl->r_zp;
/* Ensure there are no other locks */
ASSERT(avl_numnodes(&zp->z_range_avl) == 1);
ASSERT(rl->r_off == 0);
ASSERT(rl->r_type == RL_WRITER);
ASSERT(!rl->r_proxy);
ASSERT3U(rl->r_len, ==, UINT64_MAX);
ASSERT3U(rl->r_cnt, ==, 1);
mutex_enter(&zp->z_range_lock);
rl->r_off = off;
rl->r_len = len;
mutex_exit(&zp->z_range_lock);
if (rl->r_write_wanted)
cv_broadcast(&rl->r_wr_cv);
if (rl->r_read_wanted)
cv_broadcast(&rl->r_rd_cv);
}
/*
* AVL comparison function used to order range locks
* Locks are ordered on the start offset of the range.
*/
int
zfs_range_compare(const void *arg1, const void *arg2)
{
const rl_t *rl1 = arg1;
const rl_t *rl2 = arg2;
if (rl1->r_off > rl2->r_off)
return (1);
if (rl1->r_off < rl2->r_off)
return (-1);
return (0);
}