tracked BAW actually is.
The net80211 code that completes a BAR will set tid->txa_start (the
BAW start) to whatever value was called when sending the BAR.
Now, in case there's bugs in my driver code that cause the BAW
to slip along, we should make sure that the new BAW we start
at is actually what we currently have it at, not what we've sent.
This totally breaks the specification and so this stays a printf().
If it happens then I need to know and fix it.
Whilst here, add some debugging updates:
* add TID logging to places where it's useful;
* use SEQNO().
match how it's used.
This is another bug that led to aggregate traffic hanging because
the BAW tracking stopped being accurate. In this instance, a filtered
frame that exceeded retries would return a non-error, which would
mean the caller would never remove it from the BAW. But it wouldn't
be added to the filtered list, so it would be lost forever. There'd
thus be a hole in the BAW that would never get transmitted and
this leads to a traffic hang.
Tested:
* Routerstation Pro, AR9220 AP
we did suspend it.
The whole suspend/resume TID queue thing is supposed to be a matched
reference count - a subsystem (eg addba negotiation, BAR transmission,
filtered frames, etc) is supposed to call pause() once and then resume()
once.
ath_tx_tid_filt_comp_complete() is called upon the completion of any
filtered frame, regardless of whether the driver had aleady seen
a filtered frame and called pause().
So only call resume() if tid->isfiltered = 1, which indicates that
we had called pause() once.
This fixes a seemingly whacked and different problem - traffic hangs.
What was actually going on:
* There'd be some marginal link with crappy behaviour, causing filtered
frames and BAR TXing to occur;
* A BAR TX would occur, setting the new BAW (block-ack window) to seqno n;
* .. and pause() would be called, blocking further transmission;
* A filtered frame completion would occur from the hardware, but with
tid->isfiltered = 0 which indiciates we haven't actually marked
the queue yet as filtered;
* ath_tx_tid_filt_comp_complete() would call resume(), continuing
transmission;
* Some frames would be queued to the hardware, since the TID is now no
longer paused;
* .. and if some make it out and ACked successfully, the new BAW
may be seqno n+1 or more;
* .. then the BAR TX completes and sets the new seqno back to n.
At this point the BAW tracking would be loopy because the BAW
start was modified but the BAW ring buffer wasn't updated in lock
step.
Tested:
* Routerstation Pro + AR9220 AP
These are needed to diagnose TX hangs that I and hiren are seeing.
Without it, the only way we'll see debugging is by having ATH_DEBUG_SW_TX
enabled and that is going to be very, very spammy.
ATH_DEBUG_RESET is fine; it's only going to be done during stuck beacon
situations in AP mode.
Whilst I'm here, and now that it's behind debugging, let's just disable
the "print only one" conditional. I'll eventually make it more tunable.
Tested:
* AR9220, hostap mode.
device is asleep.
This doesn't avoid logging errors for things that are actually OK to
access whilst the chip is asleep (eg, the RTC registers (0x7000->0x70ff
on the AR5416 and later.)
But, this is a pretty good indicator if things are accessed incorrectly.
Tested:
* AR5416, STA
This way the state changes from sleep->awake before the registers are poked
and from awake->sleep after the registers are poked.
This way spurious warnings aren't printed by my (to be committed)
debugging code.
Tested:
* AR5416, STA
Yes, this means that sc_invalid is slightly racy, but there are other
issues here which need fixing.
This fixes a source of eventual LORs - ath_init() grabs ATH_LOCK to do
work and releases it before it calls ieee80211_start_all().
ieee80211_start_all() will grab the net80211 comlock to iterate over
the VAPs.
TODO:
* .. I should just migrate the ieee80211_start_all() work to a
deferred task so it can be done later; it doesn't have to be
immediately done.
Tested:
* AR5416, STA mode
private per-chip HAL.
This allows the ah_osdep.[ch] code to check whether the power state is
valid for doing chip programming.
It should be a no-op for normal driver work but it does require a
clean kernel/module rebuild, as the size of HAL structures have changed.
Now, this doesn't track whether the hardware is ACTUALLY awake,
as NETWORK_SLEEP wakes the chip up for a short period when traffic
is received. This doesn't actually set the power mode to AWAKE, so
we have to be careful about how we touch things.
But it's enough to start down the path of implementing station mode
chipset power savings, as a large part of the silliness is making
sure the chip is awake during periodic calibration / ANI and
random places where transmit may be occuring. I'd rather not a repeat
of debugging power save on ath9k, where races with calibration
and transmit path stuff took a couple years to shake out.
Tested:
* AR5416, STA mode
The origin of WEP comes from IEEE Std 802.11-1997 where it defines
whether the frame body of MAC frame has been encrypted using WEP
algorithm or not.
IEEE Std. 802.11-2007 changes WEP to Protected Frame, indicates
whether the frame is protected by a cryptographic encapsulation
algorithm.
Reviewed by: adrian, rpaulo
freeing them.
The current code would walk the list and call the buffer free, which
didn't remove it from any lists before pushing it back on the free list.
Tested: AR9485, STA mode
Noticed by: dillon@apollo.dragonflybsd.org
to this event, adding if_var.h to files that do need it. Also, include
all includes that now are included due to implicit pollution via if_var.h
Sponsored by: Netflix
Sponsored by: Nginx, Inc.
The AR5212 series of MACs implement the same channel counters as the
later 11n chips - except, of course, the 11n specific counter (extension
channel busy.)
This allows users of these NICs to use 'athsurvey' to see how busy their
current channel is.
Tested:
* AR5212, AR2413 NICs, STA mode
Approved by: re@ (gleb)
This occurs at RX DMA start, even though the RX FIFO has plenty of
space. I'll go figure out why, but this shouldn't cause people to
be spammed by these messages.
The AHB code:
* hard coded the AR9130 device id;
* assumes a 4k flash calibration space.
This code now extends this:
* hint.ath.X.eepromsize now overrides the eeprom range, instead of 4k
* hint.ath.X.device_id and hint.ath.X.vendor_id can now be overridden.
Tested:
* AR9330 board (Carambola 2)
This hasn't yet been tested as unfortunately the AR3012 I have doesn't
have the "real" firmware on it; it shipped with the cut down HCI firmware
that only understands enough to accept a new firmware image.
* Linux ath9k (GPIO constants)
* Add the LNA configuration table entries for AR933x/AR9485
* Add a chip-dependent LNA signal level delta in the startup path
* Add a TODO list for the stuff I haven't yet ported over but
I haven't.
Tested:
* AR9462 with LNA diversity enabled
The reference HAL pushes a config group parameter to the driver layer
to inform it which particular chip behaviour to implement.
This particular value tags it as an AR9285.
The AR9485 chip and AR933x SoC both implement LNA diversity.
There are a few extra things that need to happen before this can be
flipped on for those chips (mostly to do with setting up the different
bias values and LNA1/LNA2 RSSI differences) but the first stage is
putting this code into the driver layer so it can be reused.
This has the added benefit of making it easier to expose configuration
options and diagnostic information via the ioctl API. That's not yet
being done but it sure would be nice to do so.
Tested:
* AR9285, with LNA diversity enabled
* AR9285, with LNA diversity disabled in EEPROM
for the WB195 combo NIC - an AR9285 w/ an AR3011 USB bluetooth NIC.
The AR3011 is wired up using a 3-wire coexistence scheme to the AR9285.
The code in if_ath_btcoex.c sets up the initial hardware mapping
and coexistence configuration. There's nothing special about it -
it's static; it doesn't try to configure bluetooth / MAC traffic priorities
or try to figure out what's actually going on. It's enough to stop basic
bluetooth traffic from causing traffic stalls and diassociation from
the wireless network.
To use this code, you must have the above NIC. No, it won't work
for the AR9287+AR3012, nor the AR9485, AR9462 or AR955x combo cards.
Then you set a kernel hint before boot or before kldload, where 'X'
is the unit number of your AR9285 NIC:
# kenv hint.ath.X.btcoex_profile=wb195
This will then appear in your boot messages:
[100482] athX: Enabling WB195 BTCOEX
This code is going to evolve pretty quickly (well, depending upon my
spare time) so don't assume the btcoex API is going to stay stable.
In order to use the bluetooth side, you must also load in firmware using
ath3kfw and the binary firmware file (ath3k-1.fw in my case.)
Tested:
* AR9280, no interference
* WB195 - AR9285 + AR3011 combo; STA mode; basic bluetooth inquiries
were enough to cause traffic stalls and disassociations. This has
stopped with the btcoex profile code.
TODO:
* Importantly - the AR9285 needs ASPM disabled if bluetooth coexistence
is enabled. No, I don't know why. It's likely some kind of bug to do
with the AR3011 sending bluetooth coexistence signals whilst the device
is asleep. Since we don't actually sleep the MAC just yet, it shouldn't
be a problem. That said, to be totally correct:
+ ASPM should be disabled - upon attach and wakeup
+ The PCIe powersave HAL code should never be called
Look at what the ath9k driver does for inspiration.
* Add WB197 (AR9287+AR3012) support
* Add support for the AR9485, which is another combo like the AR9285
* The later NICs have a different signaling mechanism between the MAC
and the bluetooth device; I haven't even begun to experiment with
making that HAL code work. But it should be a lot more automatic.
* The hardware can do much more interesting traffic weighting with
bluetooth and wifi traffic. None of this is currently used.
Ideally someone would code up something to watch the bluetooth traffic
GPIO (via an interrupt) and then watch it go high/low; then figure out
what the bluetooth traffic is and adjust things appropriately.
* If I get the time I may add in some code to at least track this stuff
and expose statistics. But it's up to someone else to experiment with
the bluetooth coexistence support and add the interesting stuff (like
"real" detection of bulk, audio, etc bluetooth traffic patterns and
change wifi parameters appropriately - eg, maximum aggregate length,
transmit power, using quiet time to control TX duty cycle, etc.)
* Call the bluetooth setup function during the reset path, so the bluetooth
settings are actually initialised.
* Call the AR9285 diversity functions during bluetooth setup; so the AR9285
diversity and antenna configuration registers are correctly programmed
* Misc debugging info.
Tested:
* AR9285+AR3011 bluetooth combo; this code itself doesn't enable bluetooth
coexistence but it's part of what I'm currently using.
Now that I understand what's going on - and the RX antenna array maps
to what the receive LNA configuration actually is - I feel comfortable
in enabling this.
If people do have issues with this, there's enough debugging now available
that we have a chance to diagnose it without writing it up as 'weird
crap.'
Tested:
* AR9285 STA w/ diversity combining enabled in EEPROM
TODO:
* (More) testing in hostap mode
and controlling this form of antenna diversity) - print out the AR9285
antenna diversity configuration at attach time.
This will help track down and diagose if/when people have connectivity
issues on cards (eg if they connect a single antenna to LNA1, yet the
card has RX configured to only occur on LNA2.)
Tested:
* AR9285 w/ antenna diversity enabled in EEPROM;
* AR9285 w/ antenna diversity disabled in EEPROM; mapping only to a
single antenna (LNA1.)
the RX antenna field.
The AR9285/AR9485 use an LNA mixer to determine how to combine the signals
from the two antennas. This is encoded in the RSSI fields (ctl/ext) for
chain 2. So, let's use that here.
This maps RX antennas 0->3 to the RX mixer configuration used to
receive a frame. There's more that can be done but this is good enough
to diagnose if the hardware is doing "odd" things like trying to
receive frames on LNA2 (ie, antenna 2 or "alt" antenna) when there's
only one antenna connected.
Tested:
* AR9285, STA mode
for the RX path.
This is different to the div comb HAL flag, that says it actually
can use this for RX diversity (the "slow" diversity path implemented
but disabled in the AR9285 HAL code.)
Tested:
* AR9285, STA operation
* Grab the reset lock first, so any subsequent interrupt, TX, RX work
will fail
* Then shut down interrupts
* Then wait for TX/RX to finish running
At this point no further work will be running, so it's safe to do the
reset path code.
PR: kern/179232
The main problem here is that fast and driver RX diversity isn't actually
configured; I need to figure out why that is. That said, this makes
the single-antenna connected AR9285 and AR2427 (AR9285 w/ no 11n) work
correctly.
PR: kern/179269
and if queue mechanism; also fix up (non-11n) TX fragment handling.
This may result in a bit of a performance drop for now but I plan on
debugging and resolving this at a later stage.
Whilst here, fix the transmit path so fragment transmission works.
The TX fragmentation handling is a bit more special. In order to
correctly transmit TX fragments, there's a bunch of corner cases that
need to be handled:
* They must be transmitted back to back, in the same order..
* .. ie, you need to hold the TX lock whilst transmitting this
set of fragments rather than interleaving it with other MSDUs
destined to other nodes;
* The length of the next fragment is required when transmitting, in
order to correctly set the NAV field in the current frame to the
length of the next frame; which requires ..
* .. that we know the transmit duration of the next frame, which ..
* .. requires us to set the rate of all fragments to the same length,
or make the decision up-front, etc.
To facilitate this, I've added a new ath_buf field to describe the
length of the next fragment. This avoids having to keep the mbuf
chain together. This used to work before my 11n TX path work because
the ath_tx_start() routine would be handed a single mbuf with m_nextpkt
pointing to the next frame, and that would be maintained all the way
up to when the duration calculation was done. This doesn't hold
true any longer - the actual queuing may occur at any point in the
future (think ath_node TID software queuing) so this information
needs to be maintained.
Right now this does work for non-11n frames but it doesn't at all
enforce the same rate control decision for all frames in the fragment.
I plan on fixing this in a followup commit.
RTS/CTS has the same issue, I'll look at fixing this in a subsequent
commit.
Finaly, 11n fragment support requires the driver to have fully
decided what the rate scenario setup is - including 20/40MHz,
short/long GI, STBC, LDPC, number of streams, etc. Right now that
decision is (currently) made _after_ the NAV field value is updated.
I'll fix all of this in subsequent commits.
Tested:
* AR5416, STA, transmitting 11abg fragments
* AR5416, STA, 11n fragments work but the NAV field is incorrect for
the reasons above.
TODO:
* It would be nice to be able to queue mbufs per-node and per-TID so
we can only queue ath_buf entries when it's time to assemble frames
to send to the hardware.
But honestly, we should just do that level of software queue management
in net80211 rather than ath(4), so I'm going to leave this alone for now.
* More thorough AP, mesh and adhoc testing.
* Ensure that net80211 doesn't hand us fragmented frames when A-MPDU has
been negotiated, as we can't do software retransmission of fragments.
* .. set CLRDMASK when transmitting fragments, just to ensure.
traffic.
When transmitting non-aggregate traffic, we need to keep the hardware
busy whilst transmitting or small bursts in txdone/tx latency will
kill us.
This restores non-aggregate iperf performance, especially when doing
TDMA.
Tested:
* AR5416<->AR5416, TDMA
* AR5416 STA <-> AR9280 AP
of course.)
There's a few things that needed to happen:
* In case someone decides to set the beacon transmission rate to be
at an MCS rate, use the MCS-aware version of the duration calculation
to figure out how long the received beacon frame was.
* If TxOP enforcing is available on the hardware and we're doing TDMA,
enable it after a reset and set the TDMA guard interval to zero.
This seems to behave fine.
TODO:
* Although I haven't yet seen packet loss, the PHY errors that would be
triggered (specifically Transmit-Override-Receive) aren't enabled
by the 11n HAL. I'll have to do some work to enable these PHY errors
for debugging.
What broke:
* My recent changes to the TX queue handling has resulted in the driver
not keeping the hardware queue properly filled when doing non-aggregate
traffic. I have a patch to commit soon which fixes this situation
(albeit by reminding me about how my ath driver locking isn't working
out, sigh.)
So if you want to test this without updating to the next set of patches
that I commit, just bump the sysctl dev.ath.X.hwq_limit from 2 to 32.
Tested:
* AR5416 <-> AR5416, with ampdu disabled, HT40, 5GHz, MCS12+Short-GI.
I saw 30mbit/sec in both directions using a bidirectional UDP test.
