freebsd-skq/sys/compat/cloudabi/cloudabi_futex.c

1223 lines
33 KiB
C
Raw Normal View History

Import the CloudABI datatypes and create a system call table. CloudABI is a pure capability-based runtime environment for UNIX. It works similar to Capsicum, except that processes already run in capabilities mode on startup. All functionality that conflicts with this model has been omitted, making it a compact binary interface that can be supported by other operating systems without too much effort. CloudABI is 'secure by default'; the idea is that it should be safe to run arbitrary third-party binaries without requiring any explicit hardware virtualization (Bhyve) or namespace virtualization (Jails). The rights of an application are purely determined by the set of file descriptors that you grant it on startup. The datatypes and constants used by CloudABI's C library (cloudlibc) are defined in separate files called syscalldefs_mi.h (pointer size independent) and syscalldefs_md.h (pointer size dependent). We import these files in sys/contrib/cloudabi and wrap around them in cloudabi*_syscalldefs.h. We then add stubs for all of the system calls in sys/compat/cloudabi or sys/compat/cloudabi64, depending on whether the system call depends on the pointer size. We only have nine system calls that depend on the pointer size. If we ever want to support 32-bit binaries, we can simply add sys/compat/cloudabi32 and implement these nine system calls again. The next step is to send in code reviews for the individual system call implementations, but also add a sysentvec, to allow CloudABI executabled to be started through execve(). More information about CloudABI: - GitHub: https://github.com/NuxiNL/cloudlibc - Talk at BSDCan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVdF84x1EdA Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D2848 Reviewed by: emaste, brooks Obtained from: https://github.com/NuxiNL/freebsd
2015-07-09 07:20:15 +00:00
/*-
* Copyright (c) 2015 Nuxi, https://nuxi.nl/
*
* Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
* modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions
* are met:
* 1. Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
* notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
* 2. Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
* notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the
* documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
*
* THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE AUTHOR AND CONTRIBUTORS ``AS IS'' AND
* ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE
* IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE
* ARE DISCLAIMED. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE AUTHOR OR CONTRIBUTORS BE LIABLE
* FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL
* DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS
* OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION)
* HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT
* LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY
* OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF
* SUCH DAMAGE.
*/
#include <sys/cdefs.h>
__FBSDID("$FreeBSD$");
#include <sys/param.h>
#include <sys/kernel.h>
#include <sys/limits.h>
#include <sys/lock.h>
#include <sys/malloc.h>
#include <sys/mutex.h>
#include <sys/proc.h>
#include <sys/sx.h>
#include <sys/systm.h>
#include <vm/vm.h>
#include <vm/vm_param.h>
#include <vm/pmap.h>
#include <vm/vm_extern.h>
#include <vm/vm_map.h>
#include <vm/vm_object.h>
Import the CloudABI datatypes and create a system call table. CloudABI is a pure capability-based runtime environment for UNIX. It works similar to Capsicum, except that processes already run in capabilities mode on startup. All functionality that conflicts with this model has been omitted, making it a compact binary interface that can be supported by other operating systems without too much effort. CloudABI is 'secure by default'; the idea is that it should be safe to run arbitrary third-party binaries without requiring any explicit hardware virtualization (Bhyve) or namespace virtualization (Jails). The rights of an application are purely determined by the set of file descriptors that you grant it on startup. The datatypes and constants used by CloudABI's C library (cloudlibc) are defined in separate files called syscalldefs_mi.h (pointer size independent) and syscalldefs_md.h (pointer size dependent). We import these files in sys/contrib/cloudabi and wrap around them in cloudabi*_syscalldefs.h. We then add stubs for all of the system calls in sys/compat/cloudabi or sys/compat/cloudabi64, depending on whether the system call depends on the pointer size. We only have nine system calls that depend on the pointer size. If we ever want to support 32-bit binaries, we can simply add sys/compat/cloudabi32 and implement these nine system calls again. The next step is to send in code reviews for the individual system call implementations, but also add a sysentvec, to allow CloudABI executabled to be started through execve(). More information about CloudABI: - GitHub: https://github.com/NuxiNL/cloudlibc - Talk at BSDCan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVdF84x1EdA Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D2848 Reviewed by: emaste, brooks Obtained from: https://github.com/NuxiNL/freebsd
2015-07-09 07:20:15 +00:00
#include <compat/cloudabi/cloudabi_proto.h>
#include <compat/cloudabi/cloudabi_syscalldefs.h>
#include <compat/cloudabi/cloudabi_util.h>
/*
* Futexes for CloudABI.
*
* On most systems, futexes are implemented as objects of a single type
* on which a set of operations can be performed. CloudABI makes a clear
* distinction between locks and condition variables. A lock may have
* zero or more associated condition variables. A condition variable is
* always associated with exactly one lock. There is a strict topology.
* This approach has two advantages:
*
* - This topology is guaranteed to be acyclic. Requeueing of threads
* only happens in one direction (from condition variables to locks).
* This eases locking.
* - It means that a futex object for a lock exists when it is unlocked,
* but has threads waiting on associated condition variables. Threads
* can be requeued to a lock even if the thread performing the wakeup
* does not have the lock mapped in its address space.
*
* This futex implementation only implements a single lock type, namely
* a read-write lock. A regular mutex type would not be necessary, as
* the read-write lock is as efficient as a mutex if used as such.
* Userspace futex locks are 32 bits in size:
*
* - 1 bit: has threads waiting in kernel-space.
* - 1 bit: is write-locked.
* - 30 bits:
* - if write-locked: thread ID of owner.
* - if not write-locked: number of read locks held.
*
* Condition variables are also 32 bits in size. Its value is modified
* by kernel-space exclusively. Zero indicates that it has no waiting
* threads. Non-zero indicates the opposite.
*
* This implementation is optimal, in the sense that it only wakes up
* threads if they can actually continue execution. It does not suffer
* from the thundering herd problem. If multiple threads waiting on a
* condition variable need to be woken up, only a single thread is
* scheduled. All other threads are 'donated' to this thread. After the
* thread manages to reacquire the lock, it requeues its donated threads
* to the lock.
*
* TODO(ed): Integrate this functionality into kern_umtx.c instead.
* TODO(ed): Store futex objects in a hash table.
* TODO(ed): Add actual priority inheritance.
* TODO(ed): Let futex_queue also take priorities into account.
* TODO(ed): Make locking fine-grained.
* TODO(ed): Perform sleeps until an actual absolute point in time,
* instead of converting the timestamp to a relative value.
*/
struct futex_address;
struct futex_condvar;
struct futex_lock;
struct futex_queue;
struct futex_waiter;
/* Identifier of a location in memory. */
struct futex_address {
/* For process-private objects: address space of the process. */
struct vmspace * fa_vmspace;
/* For process-shared objects: VM object containing the object. */
struct vm_object * fa_vmobject;
/* Memory address within address space or offset within VM object. */
uintptr_t fa_offset;
};
/* A set of waiting threads. */
struct futex_queue {
STAILQ_HEAD(, futex_waiter) fq_list;
unsigned int fq_count;
};
/* Condition variables. */
struct futex_condvar {
/* Address of the condition variable. */
struct futex_address fc_address;
/* The lock the waiters should be moved to when signalled. */
struct futex_lock * fc_lock;
/* Threads waiting on the condition variable. */
struct futex_queue fc_waiters;
/*
* Number of threads blocked on this condition variable, or
* being blocked on the lock after being requeued.
*/
unsigned int fc_waitcount;
/* Global list pointers. */
LIST_ENTRY(futex_condvar) fc_next;
};
/* Read-write locks. */
struct futex_lock {
/* Address of the lock. */
struct futex_address fl_address;
/*
* Current owner of the lock. LOCK_UNMANAGED if the lock is
* currently not owned by the kernel. LOCK_OWNER_UNKNOWN in case
* the owner is not known (e.g., when the lock is read-locked).
*/
cloudabi_tid_t fl_owner;
#define LOCK_UNMANAGED 0x0
#define LOCK_OWNER_UNKNOWN 0x1
/* Writers blocked on the lock. */
struct futex_queue fl_writers;
/* Readers blocked on the lock. */
struct futex_queue fl_readers;
/* Number of threads blocked on this lock + condition variables. */
unsigned int fl_waitcount;
/* Global list pointers. */
LIST_ENTRY(futex_lock) fl_next;
};
/* Information associated with a thread blocked on an object. */
struct futex_waiter {
/* Thread ID. */
cloudabi_tid_t fw_tid;
/* Condition variable used for waiting. */
struct cv fw_wait;
/* Queue this waiter is currently placed in. */
struct futex_queue * fw_queue;
/* List pointers of fw_queue. */
STAILQ_ENTRY(futex_waiter) fw_next;
/* Lock has been acquired. */
bool fw_locked;
/* If not locked, threads that should block after acquiring. */
struct futex_queue fw_donated;
};
/* Global data structures. */
static MALLOC_DEFINE(M_FUTEX, "futex", "CloudABI futex");
static struct sx futex_global_lock;
SX_SYSINIT(futex_global_lock, &futex_global_lock, "CloudABI futex global lock");
static LIST_HEAD(, futex_lock) futex_lock_list =
LIST_HEAD_INITIALIZER(&futex_lock_list);
static LIST_HEAD(, futex_condvar) futex_condvar_list =
LIST_HEAD_INITIALIZER(&futex_condvar_list);
/* Utility functions. */
static void futex_lock_assert(const struct futex_lock *);
static struct futex_lock *futex_lock_lookup_locked(struct futex_address *);
static void futex_lock_release(struct futex_lock *);
static int futex_lock_tryrdlock(struct futex_lock *, cloudabi_lock_t *);
static int futex_lock_unmanage(struct futex_lock *, cloudabi_lock_t *);
static int futex_lock_update_owner(struct futex_lock *, cloudabi_lock_t *);
static int futex_lock_wake_up_next(struct futex_lock *, cloudabi_lock_t *);
static unsigned int futex_queue_count(const struct futex_queue *);
static void futex_queue_init(struct futex_queue *);
static void futex_queue_requeue(struct futex_queue *, struct futex_queue *,
unsigned int);
static int futex_queue_sleep(struct futex_queue *, struct futex_lock *,
struct futex_waiter *, struct thread *, cloudabi_clockid_t,
cloudabi_timestamp_t, cloudabi_timestamp_t);
static cloudabi_tid_t futex_queue_tid_best(const struct futex_queue *);
static void futex_queue_wake_up_all(struct futex_queue *);
static void futex_queue_wake_up_best(struct futex_queue *);
static void futex_queue_wake_up_donate(struct futex_queue *, unsigned int);
static int futex_user_load(uint32_t *, uint32_t *);
static int futex_user_store(uint32_t *, uint32_t);
static int futex_user_cmpxchg(uint32_t *, uint32_t, uint32_t *, uint32_t);
/*
* futex_address operations.
*/
static int
futex_address_create(struct futex_address *fa, struct thread *td,
const void *object, cloudabi_mflags_t scope)
{
struct vmspace *vs;
struct vm_object *vo;
vm_map_t map;
vm_map_entry_t entry;
vm_pindex_t pindex;
vm_prot_t prot;
boolean_t wired;
/*
* Most of the time objects are stored in privately mapped
* anonymous memory. For these objects we wouldn't need to look
* up the corresponding VM object. The scope hint provided by
* userspace allows us to skip the VM map lookup for the common
* case.
*
* POSIX does permit enabling PTHREAD_PROCESS_SHARED on a lock
* stored in a private mapping, at the cost of additional
* performance overhead. Fall back to identifying the object by
* virtual memory address if the mapping isn't shared.
*/
vs = td->td_proc->p_vmspace;
switch (scope) {
case CLOUDABI_MAP_SHARED:
map = &vs->vm_map;
if (vm_map_lookup(&map, (vm_offset_t)object,
VM_PROT_COPY | VM_PROT_WRITE, &entry, &vo, &pindex, &prot,
&wired) != KERN_SUCCESS)
return (EFAULT);
if (entry->inheritance == VM_INHERIT_SHARE) {
/*
* Address corresponds to a shared mapping.
* Identify the address by its VM object.
*/
fa->fa_vmspace = NULL;
fa->fa_vmobject = vo;
vm_object_reference(vo);
fa->fa_offset = entry->offset - entry->start +
(vm_offset_t)object;
vm_map_lookup_done(map, entry);
return (0);
}
vm_map_lookup_done(map, entry);
/* FALLTHROUGH */
case CLOUDABI_MAP_PRIVATE:
/*
* Address corresponds to a private mapping. Never
* identify the address by its VM object, as shadow
* objects may get inserted if another thread forks.
* Simply use the VM space instead.
*/
fa->fa_vmspace = vs;
fa->fa_vmobject = NULL;
fa->fa_offset = (uintptr_t)object;
return (0);
default:
return (EINVAL);
}
}
static void
futex_address_free(struct futex_address *fa)
{
if (fa->fa_vmobject != NULL)
vm_object_deallocate(fa->fa_vmobject);
}
static bool
futex_address_match(const struct futex_address *fa1,
const struct futex_address *fa2)
{
/* Either fa_vmspace or fa_vmobject is NULL. */
return (fa1->fa_vmspace == fa2->fa_vmspace &&
fa1->fa_vmobject == fa2->fa_vmobject &&
fa1->fa_offset == fa2->fa_offset);
}
/*
* futex_condvar operations.
*/
static void
futex_condvar_assert(const struct futex_condvar *fc)
{
KASSERT(fc->fc_waitcount >= futex_queue_count(&fc->fc_waiters),
("Total number of waiters cannot be smaller than the wait queue"));
futex_lock_assert(fc->fc_lock);
}
static int
futex_condvar_lookup(struct thread *td, const cloudabi_condvar_t *address,
cloudabi_mflags_t scope, struct futex_condvar **fcret)
{
struct futex_address fa_condvar;
struct futex_condvar *fc;
int error;
error = futex_address_create(&fa_condvar, td, address, scope);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
sx_xlock(&futex_global_lock);
LIST_FOREACH(fc, &futex_condvar_list, fc_next) {
if (futex_address_match(&fc->fc_address, &fa_condvar)) {
/* Found matching lock object. */
futex_address_free(&fa_condvar);
futex_condvar_assert(fc);
*fcret = fc;
return (0);
}
}
sx_xunlock(&futex_global_lock);
futex_address_free(&fa_condvar);
return (ENOENT);
}
static int
futex_condvar_lookup_or_create(struct thread *td,
const cloudabi_condvar_t *condvar, cloudabi_mflags_t condvar_scope,
const cloudabi_lock_t *lock, cloudabi_mflags_t lock_scope,
struct futex_condvar **fcret)
{
struct futex_address fa_condvar, fa_lock;
struct futex_condvar *fc;
struct futex_lock *fl;
int error;
error = futex_address_create(&fa_condvar, td, condvar, condvar_scope);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
error = futex_address_create(&fa_lock, td, lock, lock_scope);
if (error != 0) {
futex_address_free(&fa_condvar);
return (error);
}
sx_xlock(&futex_global_lock);
LIST_FOREACH(fc, &futex_condvar_list, fc_next) {
if (!futex_address_match(&fc->fc_address, &fa_condvar))
continue;
fl = fc->fc_lock;
if (!futex_address_match(&fl->fl_address, &fa_lock)) {
/* Condition variable is owned by a different lock. */
futex_address_free(&fa_condvar);
futex_address_free(&fa_lock);
sx_xunlock(&futex_global_lock);
return (EINVAL);
}
/* Found fully matching condition variable. */
futex_address_free(&fa_condvar);
futex_address_free(&fa_lock);
futex_condvar_assert(fc);
*fcret = fc;
return (0);
}
/* None found. Create new condition variable object. */
fc = malloc(sizeof(*fc), M_FUTEX, M_WAITOK);
fc->fc_address = fa_condvar;
fc->fc_lock = futex_lock_lookup_locked(&fa_lock);
futex_queue_init(&fc->fc_waiters);
fc->fc_waitcount = 0;
LIST_INSERT_HEAD(&futex_condvar_list, fc, fc_next);
*fcret = fc;
return (0);
}
static void
futex_condvar_release(struct futex_condvar *fc)
{
struct futex_lock *fl;
futex_condvar_assert(fc);
fl = fc->fc_lock;
if (fc->fc_waitcount == 0) {
/* Condition variable has no waiters. Deallocate it. */
futex_address_free(&fc->fc_address);
LIST_REMOVE(fc, fc_next);
free(fc, M_FUTEX);
}
futex_lock_release(fl);
}
static int
futex_condvar_unmanage(struct futex_condvar *fc,
cloudabi_condvar_t *condvar)
{
if (futex_queue_count(&fc->fc_waiters) != 0)
return (0);
return (futex_user_store(condvar, CLOUDABI_CONDVAR_HAS_NO_WAITERS));
}
/*
* futex_lock operations.
*/
static void
futex_lock_assert(const struct futex_lock *fl)
{
/*
* A futex lock can only be kernel-managed if it has waiters.
* Vice versa: if a futex lock has waiters, it must be
* kernel-managed.
*/
KASSERT((fl->fl_owner == LOCK_UNMANAGED) ==
(futex_queue_count(&fl->fl_readers) == 0 &&
futex_queue_count(&fl->fl_writers) == 0),
("Managed locks must have waiting threads"));
KASSERT(fl->fl_waitcount != 0 || fl->fl_owner == LOCK_UNMANAGED,
("Lock with no waiters must be unmanaged"));
}
static int
futex_lock_lookup(struct thread *td, const cloudabi_lock_t *address,
cloudabi_mflags_t scope, struct futex_lock **flret)
{
struct futex_address fa;
int error;
error = futex_address_create(&fa, td, address, scope);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
sx_xlock(&futex_global_lock);
*flret = futex_lock_lookup_locked(&fa);
return (0);
}
static struct futex_lock *
futex_lock_lookup_locked(struct futex_address *fa)
{
struct futex_lock *fl;
LIST_FOREACH(fl, &futex_lock_list, fl_next) {
if (futex_address_match(&fl->fl_address, fa)) {
/* Found matching lock object. */
futex_address_free(fa);
futex_lock_assert(fl);
return (fl);
}
}
/* None found. Create new lock object. */
fl = malloc(sizeof(*fl), M_FUTEX, M_WAITOK);
fl->fl_address = *fa;
fl->fl_owner = LOCK_UNMANAGED;
futex_queue_init(&fl->fl_readers);
futex_queue_init(&fl->fl_writers);
fl->fl_waitcount = 0;
LIST_INSERT_HEAD(&futex_lock_list, fl, fl_next);
return (fl);
}
static int
futex_lock_rdlock(struct futex_lock *fl, struct thread *td,
cloudabi_lock_t *lock, cloudabi_clockid_t clock_id,
cloudabi_timestamp_t timeout, cloudabi_timestamp_t precision)
{
struct futex_waiter fw;
int error;
error = futex_lock_tryrdlock(fl, lock);
if (error == EBUSY) {
/* Suspend execution. */
KASSERT(fl->fl_owner != LOCK_UNMANAGED,
("Attempted to sleep on an unmanaged lock"));
error = futex_queue_sleep(&fl->fl_readers, fl, &fw, td,
clock_id, timeout, precision);
KASSERT((error == 0) == fw.fw_locked,
("Should have locked write lock on success"));
KASSERT(futex_queue_count(&fw.fw_donated) == 0,
("Lock functions cannot receive threads"));
}
if (error != 0)
futex_lock_unmanage(fl, lock);
return (error);
}
static void
futex_lock_release(struct futex_lock *fl)
{
futex_lock_assert(fl);
if (fl->fl_waitcount == 0) {
/* Lock object is unreferenced. Deallocate it. */
KASSERT(fl->fl_owner == LOCK_UNMANAGED,
("Attempted to free a managed lock"));
futex_address_free(&fl->fl_address);
LIST_REMOVE(fl, fl_next);
free(fl, M_FUTEX);
}
sx_xunlock(&futex_global_lock);
}
static int
futex_lock_unmanage(struct futex_lock *fl, cloudabi_lock_t *lock)
{
cloudabi_lock_t cmp, old;
int error;
if (futex_queue_count(&fl->fl_readers) == 0 &&
futex_queue_count(&fl->fl_writers) == 0) {
/* Lock should be unmanaged. */
fl->fl_owner = LOCK_UNMANAGED;
/* Clear kernel-managed bit. */
error = futex_user_load(lock, &old);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
for (;;) {
cmp = old;
error = futex_user_cmpxchg(lock, cmp, &old,
cmp & ~CLOUDABI_LOCK_KERNEL_MANAGED);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
if (old == cmp)
break;
}
}
return (0);
}
/* Sets an owner of a lock, based on a userspace lock value. */
static void
futex_lock_set_owner(struct futex_lock *fl, cloudabi_lock_t lock)
{
/* Lock has no explicit owner. */
if ((lock & ~CLOUDABI_LOCK_WRLOCKED) == 0) {
fl->fl_owner = LOCK_OWNER_UNKNOWN;
return;
}
lock &= ~(CLOUDABI_LOCK_WRLOCKED | CLOUDABI_LOCK_KERNEL_MANAGED);
/* Don't allow userspace to silently unlock. */
if (lock == LOCK_UNMANAGED) {
fl->fl_owner = LOCK_OWNER_UNKNOWN;
return;
}
fl->fl_owner = lock;
}
static int
futex_lock_unlock(struct futex_lock *fl, struct thread *td,
cloudabi_lock_t *lock)
{
int error;
/* Validate that this thread is allowed to unlock. */
error = futex_lock_update_owner(fl, lock);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
if (fl->fl_owner != LOCK_UNMANAGED && fl->fl_owner != td->td_tid)
return (EPERM);
return (futex_lock_wake_up_next(fl, lock));
}
/* Syncs in the owner of the lock from userspace if needed. */
static int
futex_lock_update_owner(struct futex_lock *fl, cloudabi_lock_t *address)
{
cloudabi_lock_t lock;
int error;
if (fl->fl_owner == LOCK_OWNER_UNKNOWN) {
error = futex_user_load(address, &lock);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
futex_lock_set_owner(fl, lock);
}
return (0);
}
static int
futex_lock_tryrdlock(struct futex_lock *fl, cloudabi_lock_t *address)
{
cloudabi_lock_t old, cmp;
int error;
if (fl->fl_owner != LOCK_UNMANAGED) {
/* Lock is already acquired. */
return (EBUSY);
}
old = CLOUDABI_LOCK_UNLOCKED;
for (;;) {
if ((old & CLOUDABI_LOCK_KERNEL_MANAGED) != 0) {
/*
* Userspace lock is kernel-managed, even though
* the kernel disagrees.
*/
return (EINVAL);
}
if ((old & CLOUDABI_LOCK_WRLOCKED) == 0) {
/*
* Lock is not write-locked. Attempt to acquire
* it by increasing the read count.
*/
cmp = old;
error = futex_user_cmpxchg(address, cmp, &old, cmp + 1);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
if (old == cmp) {
/* Success. */
return (0);
}
} else {
/* Lock is write-locked. Make it kernel-managed. */
cmp = old;
error = futex_user_cmpxchg(address, cmp, &old,
cmp | CLOUDABI_LOCK_KERNEL_MANAGED);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
if (old == cmp) {
/* Success. */
futex_lock_set_owner(fl, cmp);
return (EBUSY);
}
}
}
}
static int
futex_lock_trywrlock(struct futex_lock *fl, cloudabi_lock_t *address,
cloudabi_tid_t tid, bool force_kernel_managed)
{
cloudabi_lock_t old, new, cmp;
int error;
if (fl->fl_owner == tid) {
/* Attempted to acquire lock recursively. */
return (EDEADLK);
}
if (fl->fl_owner != LOCK_UNMANAGED) {
/* Lock is already acquired. */
return (EBUSY);
}
old = CLOUDABI_LOCK_UNLOCKED;
for (;;) {
if ((old & CLOUDABI_LOCK_KERNEL_MANAGED) != 0) {
/*
* Userspace lock is kernel-managed, even though
* the kernel disagrees.
*/
return (EINVAL);
}
if (old == (tid | CLOUDABI_LOCK_WRLOCKED)) {
/* Attempted to acquire lock recursively. */
return (EDEADLK);
}
if (old == CLOUDABI_LOCK_UNLOCKED) {
/* Lock is unlocked. Attempt to acquire it. */
new = tid | CLOUDABI_LOCK_WRLOCKED;
if (force_kernel_managed)
new |= CLOUDABI_LOCK_KERNEL_MANAGED;
error = futex_user_cmpxchg(address,
CLOUDABI_LOCK_UNLOCKED, &old, new);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
if (old == CLOUDABI_LOCK_UNLOCKED) {
/* Success. */
if (force_kernel_managed)
fl->fl_owner = tid;
return (0);
}
} else {
/* Lock is still locked. Make it kernel-managed. */
cmp = old;
error = futex_user_cmpxchg(address, cmp, &old,
cmp | CLOUDABI_LOCK_KERNEL_MANAGED);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
if (old == cmp) {
/* Success. */
futex_lock_set_owner(fl, cmp);
return (EBUSY);
}
}
}
}
static int
futex_lock_wake_up_next(struct futex_lock *fl, cloudabi_lock_t *lock)
{
cloudabi_tid_t tid;
int error;
/*
* Determine which thread(s) to wake up. Prefer waking up
* writers over readers to prevent write starvation.
*/
if (futex_queue_count(&fl->fl_writers) > 0) {
/* Transfer ownership to a single write-locker. */
if (futex_queue_count(&fl->fl_writers) > 1 ||
futex_queue_count(&fl->fl_readers) > 0) {
/* Lock should remain managed afterwards. */
tid = futex_queue_tid_best(&fl->fl_writers);
error = futex_user_store(lock,
tid | CLOUDABI_LOCK_WRLOCKED |
CLOUDABI_LOCK_KERNEL_MANAGED);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
futex_queue_wake_up_best(&fl->fl_writers);
fl->fl_owner = tid;
} else {
/* Lock can become unmanaged afterwards. */
error = futex_user_store(lock,
futex_queue_tid_best(&fl->fl_writers) |
CLOUDABI_LOCK_WRLOCKED);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
futex_queue_wake_up_best(&fl->fl_writers);
fl->fl_owner = LOCK_UNMANAGED;
}
} else {
/* Transfer ownership to all read-lockers (if any). */
error = futex_user_store(lock,
futex_queue_count(&fl->fl_readers));
if (error != 0)
return (error);
/* Wake up all threads. */
futex_queue_wake_up_all(&fl->fl_readers);
fl->fl_owner = LOCK_UNMANAGED;
}
return (0);
}
static int
futex_lock_wrlock(struct futex_lock *fl, struct thread *td,
cloudabi_lock_t *lock, cloudabi_clockid_t clock_id,
cloudabi_timestamp_t timeout, cloudabi_timestamp_t precision,
struct futex_queue *donated)
{
struct futex_waiter fw;
int error;
error = futex_lock_trywrlock(fl, lock, td->td_tid,
futex_queue_count(donated) > 0);
if (error == 0 || error == EBUSY) {
/* Put donated threads in queue before suspending. */
KASSERT(futex_queue_count(donated) == 0 ||
fl->fl_owner != LOCK_UNMANAGED,
("Lock should be managed if we are going to donate"));
futex_queue_requeue(donated, &fl->fl_writers, UINT_MAX);
} else {
/*
* This thread cannot deal with the donated threads.
* Wake up the next thread and let it try it by itself.
*/
futex_queue_wake_up_donate(donated, UINT_MAX);
}
if (error == EBUSY) {
/* Suspend execution if the lock was busy. */
KASSERT(fl->fl_owner != LOCK_UNMANAGED,
("Attempted to sleep on an unmanaged lock"));
error = futex_queue_sleep(&fl->fl_writers, fl, &fw, td,
clock_id, timeout, precision);
KASSERT((error == 0) == fw.fw_locked,
("Should have locked write lock on success"));
KASSERT(futex_queue_count(&fw.fw_donated) == 0,
("Lock functions cannot receive threads"));
}
if (error != 0)
futex_lock_unmanage(fl, lock);
return (error);
}
/*
* futex_queue operations.
*/
static cloudabi_tid_t
futex_queue_tid_best(const struct futex_queue *fq)
{
return (STAILQ_FIRST(&fq->fq_list)->fw_tid);
}
static unsigned int
futex_queue_count(const struct futex_queue *fq)
{
return (fq->fq_count);
}
static void
futex_queue_init(struct futex_queue *fq)
{
STAILQ_INIT(&fq->fq_list);
fq->fq_count = 0;
}
/* Converts a relative timestamp to an sbintime. */
static sbintime_t
futex_queue_convert_timestamp_relative(cloudabi_timestamp_t ts)
{
cloudabi_timestamp_t s, ns;
s = ts / 1000000000;
ns = ts % 1000000000;
if (s > INT32_MAX)
return (INT64_MAX);
return ((s << 32) + (ns << 32) / 1000000000);
}
/* Converts an absolute timestamp and precision to a pair of sbintime values. */
static int
futex_queue_convert_timestamp(struct thread *td, cloudabi_clockid_t clock_id,
cloudabi_timestamp_t timeout, cloudabi_timestamp_t precision,
sbintime_t *sbttimeout, sbintime_t *sbtprecision)
{
cloudabi_timestamp_t now;
int error;
/* Make the time relative. */
error = cloudabi_clock_time_get(td, clock_id, &now);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
timeout = timeout < now ? 0 : timeout - now;
*sbttimeout = futex_queue_convert_timestamp_relative(timeout);
*sbtprecision = futex_queue_convert_timestamp_relative(precision);
return (0);
}
static int
futex_queue_sleep(struct futex_queue *fq, struct futex_lock *fl,
struct futex_waiter *fw, struct thread *td, cloudabi_clockid_t clock_id,
cloudabi_timestamp_t timeout, cloudabi_timestamp_t precision)
{
sbintime_t sbttimeout, sbtprecision;
int error;
/* Initialize futex_waiter object. */
fw->fw_tid = td->td_tid;
fw->fw_locked = false;
futex_queue_init(&fw->fw_donated);
if (timeout != UINT64_MAX) {
/* Convert timeout duration. */
error = futex_queue_convert_timestamp(td, clock_id, timeout,
precision, &sbttimeout, &sbtprecision);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
}
/* Place object in the queue. */
fw->fw_queue = fq;
STAILQ_INSERT_TAIL(&fq->fq_list, fw, fw_next);
++fq->fq_count;
cv_init(&fw->fw_wait, "futex");
++fl->fl_waitcount;
futex_lock_assert(fl);
if (timeout == UINT64_MAX) {
/* Wait without a timeout. */
error = cv_wait_sig(&fw->fw_wait, &futex_global_lock);
} else {
/* Wait respecting the timeout. */
error = cv_timedwait_sig_sbt(&fw->fw_wait, &futex_global_lock,
sbttimeout, sbtprecision, 0);
futex_lock_assert(fl);
if (error == EWOULDBLOCK &&
fw->fw_queue != NULL && fw->fw_queue != fq) {
/*
* We got signalled on a condition variable, but
* observed a timeout while waiting to reacquire
* the lock. In other words, we didn't actually
* time out. Go back to sleep and wait for the
* lock to be reacquired.
*/
error = cv_wait_sig(&fw->fw_wait, &futex_global_lock);
}
}
futex_lock_assert(fl);
--fl->fl_waitcount;
cv_destroy(&fw->fw_wait);
fq = fw->fw_queue;
if (fq == NULL) {
/* Thread got dequeued, so we've slept successfully. */
return (0);
}
/* Thread is still enqueued. Remove it. */
KASSERT(error != 0, ("Woken up thread is still enqueued"));
STAILQ_REMOVE(&fq->fq_list, fw, futex_waiter, fw_next);
--fq->fq_count;
return (error == EWOULDBLOCK ? ETIMEDOUT : error);
}
/* Moves up to nwaiters waiters from one queue to another. */
static void
futex_queue_requeue(struct futex_queue *fqfrom, struct futex_queue *fqto,
unsigned int nwaiters)
{
struct futex_waiter *fw;
/* Move waiters to the target queue. */
while (nwaiters-- > 0 && !STAILQ_EMPTY(&fqfrom->fq_list)) {
fw = STAILQ_FIRST(&fqfrom->fq_list);
STAILQ_REMOVE_HEAD(&fqfrom->fq_list, fw_next);
--fqfrom->fq_count;
fw->fw_queue = fqto;
STAILQ_INSERT_TAIL(&fqto->fq_list, fw, fw_next);
++fqto->fq_count;
}
}
/* Wakes up all waiters in a queue. */
static void
futex_queue_wake_up_all(struct futex_queue *fq)
{
struct futex_waiter *fw;
STAILQ_FOREACH(fw, &fq->fq_list, fw_next) {
fw->fw_locked = true;
fw->fw_queue = NULL;
cv_signal(&fw->fw_wait);
}
STAILQ_INIT(&fq->fq_list);
fq->fq_count = 0;
}
/*
* Wakes up the best waiter (i.e., the waiter having the highest
* priority) in a queue.
*/
static void
futex_queue_wake_up_best(struct futex_queue *fq)
{
struct futex_waiter *fw;
fw = STAILQ_FIRST(&fq->fq_list);
fw->fw_locked = true;
fw->fw_queue = NULL;
cv_signal(&fw->fw_wait);
STAILQ_REMOVE_HEAD(&fq->fq_list, fw_next);
--fq->fq_count;
}
static void
futex_queue_wake_up_donate(struct futex_queue *fq, unsigned int nwaiters)
{
struct futex_waiter *fw;
fw = STAILQ_FIRST(&fq->fq_list);
if (fw == NULL)
return;
fw->fw_locked = false;
fw->fw_queue = NULL;
cv_signal(&fw->fw_wait);
STAILQ_REMOVE_HEAD(&fq->fq_list, fw_next);
--fq->fq_count;
futex_queue_requeue(fq, &fw->fw_donated, nwaiters);
}
/*
* futex_user operations. Used to adjust values in userspace.
*/
static int
futex_user_load(uint32_t *obj, uint32_t *val)
{
return (fueword32(obj, val) != 0 ? EFAULT : 0);
}
static int
futex_user_store(uint32_t *obj, uint32_t val)
{
return (suword32(obj, val) != 0 ? EFAULT : 0);
}
static int
futex_user_cmpxchg(uint32_t *obj, uint32_t cmp, uint32_t *old, uint32_t new)
{
return (casueword32(obj, cmp, old, new) != 0 ? EFAULT : 0);
}
/*
* Blocking calls: acquiring locks, waiting on condition variables.
*/
int
cloudabi_futex_condvar_wait(struct thread *td, cloudabi_condvar_t *condvar,
cloudabi_mflags_t condvar_scope, cloudabi_lock_t *lock,
cloudabi_mflags_t lock_scope, cloudabi_clockid_t clock_id,
cloudabi_timestamp_t timeout, cloudabi_timestamp_t precision)
{
struct futex_condvar *fc;
struct futex_lock *fl;
struct futex_waiter fw;
int error, error2;
/* Lookup condition variable object. */
error = futex_condvar_lookup_or_create(td, condvar, condvar_scope, lock,
lock_scope, &fc);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
fl = fc->fc_lock;
/*
* Set the condition variable to something other than
* CLOUDABI_CONDVAR_HAS_NO_WAITERS to make userspace threads
* call into the kernel to perform wakeups.
*/
error = futex_user_store(condvar, ~CLOUDABI_CONDVAR_HAS_NO_WAITERS);
if (error != 0) {
futex_condvar_release(fc);
return (error);
}
/* Drop the lock. */
error = futex_lock_unlock(fl, td, lock);
if (error != 0) {
futex_condvar_unmanage(fc, condvar);
futex_condvar_release(fc);
return (error);
}
/* Go to sleep. */
++fc->fc_waitcount;
error = futex_queue_sleep(&fc->fc_waiters, fc->fc_lock, &fw, td,
clock_id, timeout, precision);
if (fw.fw_locked) {
/* Waited and got the lock assigned to us. */
KASSERT(futex_queue_count(&fw.fw_donated) == 0,
("Received threads while being locked"));
} else if (error == 0 || error == ETIMEDOUT) {
if (error != 0)
futex_condvar_unmanage(fc, condvar);
/*
* Got woken up without having the lock assigned to us.
* This can happen in two cases:
*
* 1. We observed a timeout on a condition variable.
* 2. We got signalled on a condition variable while the
* associated lock is unlocked. We are the first
* thread that gets woken up. This thread is
* responsible for reacquiring the userspace lock.
*/
error2 = futex_lock_wrlock(fl, td, lock,
CLOUDABI_CLOCK_MONOTONIC, UINT64_MAX, 0, &fw.fw_donated);
if (error2 != 0)
error = error2;
} else {
KASSERT(futex_queue_count(&fw.fw_donated) == 0,
("Received threads on error"));
futex_condvar_unmanage(fc, condvar);
futex_lock_unmanage(fl, lock);
}
--fc->fc_waitcount;
futex_condvar_release(fc);
return (error);
}
int
cloudabi_futex_lock_rdlock(struct thread *td, cloudabi_lock_t *lock,
cloudabi_mflags_t scope, cloudabi_clockid_t clock_id,
cloudabi_timestamp_t timeout, cloudabi_timestamp_t precision)
{
struct futex_lock *fl;
int error;
/* Look up lock object. */
error = futex_lock_lookup(td, lock, scope, &fl);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
error = futex_lock_rdlock(fl, td, lock, clock_id, timeout,
precision);
futex_lock_release(fl);
return (error);
}
int
cloudabi_futex_lock_wrlock(struct thread *td, cloudabi_lock_t *lock,
cloudabi_mflags_t scope, cloudabi_clockid_t clock_id,
cloudabi_timestamp_t timeout, cloudabi_timestamp_t precision)
{
struct futex_lock *fl;
struct futex_queue fq;
int error;
/* Look up lock object. */
error = futex_lock_lookup(td, lock, scope, &fl);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
futex_queue_init(&fq);
error = futex_lock_wrlock(fl, td, lock, clock_id, timeout,
precision, &fq);
futex_lock_release(fl);
return (error);
}
/*
* Non-blocking calls: releasing locks, signalling condition variables.
*/
Import the CloudABI datatypes and create a system call table. CloudABI is a pure capability-based runtime environment for UNIX. It works similar to Capsicum, except that processes already run in capabilities mode on startup. All functionality that conflicts with this model has been omitted, making it a compact binary interface that can be supported by other operating systems without too much effort. CloudABI is 'secure by default'; the idea is that it should be safe to run arbitrary third-party binaries without requiring any explicit hardware virtualization (Bhyve) or namespace virtualization (Jails). The rights of an application are purely determined by the set of file descriptors that you grant it on startup. The datatypes and constants used by CloudABI's C library (cloudlibc) are defined in separate files called syscalldefs_mi.h (pointer size independent) and syscalldefs_md.h (pointer size dependent). We import these files in sys/contrib/cloudabi and wrap around them in cloudabi*_syscalldefs.h. We then add stubs for all of the system calls in sys/compat/cloudabi or sys/compat/cloudabi64, depending on whether the system call depends on the pointer size. We only have nine system calls that depend on the pointer size. If we ever want to support 32-bit binaries, we can simply add sys/compat/cloudabi32 and implement these nine system calls again. The next step is to send in code reviews for the individual system call implementations, but also add a sysentvec, to allow CloudABI executabled to be started through execve(). More information about CloudABI: - GitHub: https://github.com/NuxiNL/cloudlibc - Talk at BSDCan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVdF84x1EdA Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D2848 Reviewed by: emaste, brooks Obtained from: https://github.com/NuxiNL/freebsd
2015-07-09 07:20:15 +00:00
int
cloudabi_sys_condvar_signal(struct thread *td,
struct cloudabi_sys_condvar_signal_args *uap)
{
struct futex_condvar *fc;
struct futex_lock *fl;
cloudabi_nthreads_t nwaiters;
int error;
nwaiters = uap->nwaiters;
if (nwaiters == 0) {
/* No threads to wake up. */
return (0);
}
/* Look up futex object. */
error = futex_condvar_lookup(td, uap->condvar, uap->scope, &fc);
if (error != 0) {
/* Race condition: condition variable with no waiters. */
return (error == ENOENT ? 0 : error);
}
fl = fc->fc_lock;
if (fl->fl_owner == LOCK_UNMANAGED) {
/*
* The lock is currently not managed by the kernel,
* meaning we must attempt to acquire the userspace lock
* first. We cannot requeue threads to an unmanaged lock,
* as these threads will then never be scheduled.
*
* Unfortunately, the memory address of the lock is
* unknown from this context, meaning that we cannot
* acquire the lock on behalf of the first thread to be
* scheduled. The lock may even not be mapped within the
* address space of the current thread.
*
* To solve this, wake up a single waiter that will
* attempt to acquire the lock. Donate all of the other
* waiters that need to be woken up to this waiter, so
* it can requeue them after acquiring the lock.
*/
futex_queue_wake_up_donate(&fc->fc_waiters, nwaiters - 1);
} else {
/*
* Lock is already managed by the kernel. This makes it
* easy, as we can requeue the threads from the
* condition variable directly to the associated lock.
*/
futex_queue_requeue(&fc->fc_waiters, &fl->fl_writers, nwaiters);
}
Import the CloudABI datatypes and create a system call table. CloudABI is a pure capability-based runtime environment for UNIX. It works similar to Capsicum, except that processes already run in capabilities mode on startup. All functionality that conflicts with this model has been omitted, making it a compact binary interface that can be supported by other operating systems without too much effort. CloudABI is 'secure by default'; the idea is that it should be safe to run arbitrary third-party binaries without requiring any explicit hardware virtualization (Bhyve) or namespace virtualization (Jails). The rights of an application are purely determined by the set of file descriptors that you grant it on startup. The datatypes and constants used by CloudABI's C library (cloudlibc) are defined in separate files called syscalldefs_mi.h (pointer size independent) and syscalldefs_md.h (pointer size dependent). We import these files in sys/contrib/cloudabi and wrap around them in cloudabi*_syscalldefs.h. We then add stubs for all of the system calls in sys/compat/cloudabi or sys/compat/cloudabi64, depending on whether the system call depends on the pointer size. We only have nine system calls that depend on the pointer size. If we ever want to support 32-bit binaries, we can simply add sys/compat/cloudabi32 and implement these nine system calls again. The next step is to send in code reviews for the individual system call implementations, but also add a sysentvec, to allow CloudABI executabled to be started through execve(). More information about CloudABI: - GitHub: https://github.com/NuxiNL/cloudlibc - Talk at BSDCan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVdF84x1EdA Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D2848 Reviewed by: emaste, brooks Obtained from: https://github.com/NuxiNL/freebsd
2015-07-09 07:20:15 +00:00
/* Clear userspace condition variable if all waiters are gone. */
error = futex_condvar_unmanage(fc, uap->condvar);
futex_condvar_release(fc);
return (error);
Import the CloudABI datatypes and create a system call table. CloudABI is a pure capability-based runtime environment for UNIX. It works similar to Capsicum, except that processes already run in capabilities mode on startup. All functionality that conflicts with this model has been omitted, making it a compact binary interface that can be supported by other operating systems without too much effort. CloudABI is 'secure by default'; the idea is that it should be safe to run arbitrary third-party binaries without requiring any explicit hardware virtualization (Bhyve) or namespace virtualization (Jails). The rights of an application are purely determined by the set of file descriptors that you grant it on startup. The datatypes and constants used by CloudABI's C library (cloudlibc) are defined in separate files called syscalldefs_mi.h (pointer size independent) and syscalldefs_md.h (pointer size dependent). We import these files in sys/contrib/cloudabi and wrap around them in cloudabi*_syscalldefs.h. We then add stubs for all of the system calls in sys/compat/cloudabi or sys/compat/cloudabi64, depending on whether the system call depends on the pointer size. We only have nine system calls that depend on the pointer size. If we ever want to support 32-bit binaries, we can simply add sys/compat/cloudabi32 and implement these nine system calls again. The next step is to send in code reviews for the individual system call implementations, but also add a sysentvec, to allow CloudABI executabled to be started through execve(). More information about CloudABI: - GitHub: https://github.com/NuxiNL/cloudlibc - Talk at BSDCan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVdF84x1EdA Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D2848 Reviewed by: emaste, brooks Obtained from: https://github.com/NuxiNL/freebsd
2015-07-09 07:20:15 +00:00
}
int
cloudabi_sys_lock_unlock(struct thread *td,
struct cloudabi_sys_lock_unlock_args *uap)
{
struct futex_lock *fl;
int error;
Import the CloudABI datatypes and create a system call table. CloudABI is a pure capability-based runtime environment for UNIX. It works similar to Capsicum, except that processes already run in capabilities mode on startup. All functionality that conflicts with this model has been omitted, making it a compact binary interface that can be supported by other operating systems without too much effort. CloudABI is 'secure by default'; the idea is that it should be safe to run arbitrary third-party binaries without requiring any explicit hardware virtualization (Bhyve) or namespace virtualization (Jails). The rights of an application are purely determined by the set of file descriptors that you grant it on startup. The datatypes and constants used by CloudABI's C library (cloudlibc) are defined in separate files called syscalldefs_mi.h (pointer size independent) and syscalldefs_md.h (pointer size dependent). We import these files in sys/contrib/cloudabi and wrap around them in cloudabi*_syscalldefs.h. We then add stubs for all of the system calls in sys/compat/cloudabi or sys/compat/cloudabi64, depending on whether the system call depends on the pointer size. We only have nine system calls that depend on the pointer size. If we ever want to support 32-bit binaries, we can simply add sys/compat/cloudabi32 and implement these nine system calls again. The next step is to send in code reviews for the individual system call implementations, but also add a sysentvec, to allow CloudABI executabled to be started through execve(). More information about CloudABI: - GitHub: https://github.com/NuxiNL/cloudlibc - Talk at BSDCan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVdF84x1EdA Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D2848 Reviewed by: emaste, brooks Obtained from: https://github.com/NuxiNL/freebsd
2015-07-09 07:20:15 +00:00
error = futex_lock_lookup(td, uap->lock, uap->scope, &fl);
if (error != 0)
return (error);
error = futex_lock_unlock(fl, td, uap->lock);
futex_lock_release(fl);
return (error);
Import the CloudABI datatypes and create a system call table. CloudABI is a pure capability-based runtime environment for UNIX. It works similar to Capsicum, except that processes already run in capabilities mode on startup. All functionality that conflicts with this model has been omitted, making it a compact binary interface that can be supported by other operating systems without too much effort. CloudABI is 'secure by default'; the idea is that it should be safe to run arbitrary third-party binaries without requiring any explicit hardware virtualization (Bhyve) or namespace virtualization (Jails). The rights of an application are purely determined by the set of file descriptors that you grant it on startup. The datatypes and constants used by CloudABI's C library (cloudlibc) are defined in separate files called syscalldefs_mi.h (pointer size independent) and syscalldefs_md.h (pointer size dependent). We import these files in sys/contrib/cloudabi and wrap around them in cloudabi*_syscalldefs.h. We then add stubs for all of the system calls in sys/compat/cloudabi or sys/compat/cloudabi64, depending on whether the system call depends on the pointer size. We only have nine system calls that depend on the pointer size. If we ever want to support 32-bit binaries, we can simply add sys/compat/cloudabi32 and implement these nine system calls again. The next step is to send in code reviews for the individual system call implementations, but also add a sysentvec, to allow CloudABI executabled to be started through execve(). More information about CloudABI: - GitHub: https://github.com/NuxiNL/cloudlibc - Talk at BSDCan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SVdF84x1EdA Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D2848 Reviewed by: emaste, brooks Obtained from: https://github.com/NuxiNL/freebsd
2015-07-09 07:20:15 +00:00
}