- Add a new TCP_RXTLS_ENABLE socket option to set the encryption and
authentication algorithms and keys as well as the initial sequence
number.
- When reading from a socket using KTLS receive, applications must use
recvmsg(). Each successful call to recvmsg() will return a single
TLS record. A new TCP control message, TLS_GET_RECORD, will contain
the TLS record header of the decrypted record. The regular message
buffer passed to recvmsg() will receive the decrypted payload. This
is similar to the interface used by Linux's KTLS RX except that
Linux does not return the full TLS header in the control message.
- Add plumbing to the TOE KTLS interface to request either transmit
or receive KTLS sessions.
- When a socket is using receive KTLS, redirect reads from
soreceive_stream() into soreceive_generic().
- Note that this interface is currently only defined for TLS 1.1 and
1.2, though I believe we will be able to reuse the same interface
and structures for 1.3.
a single instance: use snd_recover also where sack_newdata was used.
Submitted by: Richard Scheffenegger
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D18811
All gotos to the label are within the #ifdef INET section, which leaves
us with an unused label. Cover the label under #ifdef INET as well to
avoid the warning and compile time error.
with this widen network epoch coverage up to tcp_connect() and udp_connect().
Revisions from r356974 and up to this revision cover D23187.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D23187
This makes it possible to retrieve per-connection statistical
information such as the receive window size, RTT, or goodput,
using a newly added TCP_STATS getsockopt(3) option, and extract
them using the stats_voistat_fetch(3) API.
See the net/tcprtt port for an example consumer of this API.
Compared to the existing TCP_INFO system, the main differences
are that this mechanism is easy to extend without breaking ABI,
and provides statistical information instead of raw "snapshots"
of values at a given point in time. stats(3) is more generic
and can be used in both userland and the kernel.
Reviewed by: thj
Tested by: thj
Obtained from: Netflix
Relnotes: yes
Sponsored by: Klara Inc, Netflix
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D20655
This allows adding more ECN related flags in the future.
No functional change intended.
Submitted by: Richard Scheffenegger
Reviewed by: rrs@, tuexen@
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D22497
This adds the glue to allocate TLS sessions and invokes it from
the TLS enable socket option handler. This also adds some counters
for active TOE sessions.
The TOE KTLS mode is returned by getsockopt(TLSTX_TLS_MODE) when
TOE KTLS is in use on a socket, but cannot be set via setsockopt().
To simplify various checks, a TLS session now includes an explicit
'mode' member set to the value returned by TLSTX_TLS_MODE. Various
places that used to check 'sw_encrypt' against NULL to determine
software vs ifnet (NIC) TLS now check 'mode' instead.
Reviewed by: np, gallatin
Sponsored by: Chelsio Communications
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D21891
KTLS adds support for in-kernel framing and encryption of Transport
Layer Security (1.0-1.2) data on TCP sockets. KTLS only supports
offload of TLS for transmitted data. Key negotation must still be
performed in userland. Once completed, transmit session keys for a
connection are provided to the kernel via a new TCP_TXTLS_ENABLE
socket option. All subsequent data transmitted on the socket is
placed into TLS frames and encrypted using the supplied keys.
Any data written to a KTLS-enabled socket via write(2), aio_write(2),
or sendfile(2) is assumed to be application data and is encoded in TLS
frames with an application data type. Individual records can be sent
with a custom type (e.g. handshake messages) via sendmsg(2) with a new
control message (TLS_SET_RECORD_TYPE) specifying the record type.
At present, rekeying is not supported though the in-kernel framework
should support rekeying.
KTLS makes use of the recently added unmapped mbufs to store TLS
frames in the socket buffer. Each TLS frame is described by a single
ext_pgs mbuf. The ext_pgs structure contains the header of the TLS
record (and trailer for encrypted records) as well as references to
the associated TLS session.
KTLS supports two primary methods of encrypting TLS frames: software
TLS and ifnet TLS.
Software TLS marks mbufs holding socket data as not ready via
M_NOTREADY similar to sendfile(2) when TLS framing information is
added to an unmapped mbuf in ktls_frame(). ktls_enqueue() is then
called to schedule TLS frames for encryption. In the case of
sendfile_iodone() calls ktls_enqueue() instead of pru_ready() leaving
the mbufs marked M_NOTREADY until encryption is completed. For other
writes (vn_sendfile when pages are available, write(2), etc.), the
PRUS_NOTREADY is set when invoking pru_send() along with invoking
ktls_enqueue().
A pool of worker threads (the "KTLS" kernel process) encrypts TLS
frames queued via ktls_enqueue(). Each TLS frame is temporarily
mapped using the direct map and passed to a software encryption
backend to perform the actual encryption.
(Note: The use of PHYS_TO_DMAP could be replaced with sf_bufs if
someone wished to make this work on architectures without a direct
map.)
KTLS supports pluggable software encryption backends. Internally,
Netflix uses proprietary pure-software backends. This commit includes
a simple backend in a new ktls_ocf.ko module that uses the kernel's
OpenCrypto framework to provide AES-GCM encryption of TLS frames. As
a result, software TLS is now a bit of a misnomer as it can make use
of hardware crypto accelerators.
Once software encryption has finished, the TLS frame mbufs are marked
ready via pru_ready(). At this point, the encrypted data appears as
regular payload to the TCP stack stored in unmapped mbufs.
ifnet TLS permits a NIC to offload the TLS encryption and TCP
segmentation. In this mode, a new send tag type (IF_SND_TAG_TYPE_TLS)
is allocated on the interface a socket is routed over and associated
with a TLS session. TLS records for a TLS session using ifnet TLS are
not marked M_NOTREADY but are passed down the stack unencrypted. The
ip_output_send() and ip6_output_send() helper functions that apply
send tags to outbound IP packets verify that the send tag of the TLS
record matches the outbound interface. If so, the packet is tagged
with the TLS send tag and sent to the interface. The NIC device
driver must recognize packets with the TLS send tag and schedule them
for TLS encryption and TCP segmentation. If the the outbound
interface does not match the interface in the TLS send tag, the packet
is dropped. In addition, a task is scheduled to refresh the TLS send
tag for the TLS session. If a new TLS send tag cannot be allocated,
the connection is dropped. If a new TLS send tag is allocated,
however, subsequent packets will be tagged with the correct TLS send
tag. (This latter case has been tested by configuring both ports of a
Chelsio T6 in a lagg and failing over from one port to another. As
the connections migrated to the new port, new TLS send tags were
allocated for the new port and connections resumed without being
dropped.)
ifnet TLS can be enabled and disabled on supported network interfaces
via new '[-]txtls[46]' options to ifconfig(8). ifnet TLS is supported
across both vlan devices and lagg interfaces using failover, lacp with
flowid enabled, or lacp with flowid enabled.
Applications may request the current KTLS mode of a connection via a
new TCP_TXTLS_MODE socket option. They can also use this socket
option to toggle between software and ifnet TLS modes.
In addition, a testing tool is available in tools/tools/switch_tls.
This is modeled on tcpdrop and uses similar syntax. However, instead
of dropping connections, -s is used to force KTLS connections to
switch to software TLS and -i is used to switch to ifnet TLS.
Various sysctls and counters are available under the kern.ipc.tls
sysctl node. The kern.ipc.tls.enable node must be set to true to
enable KTLS (it is off by default). The use of unmapped mbufs must
also be enabled via kern.ipc.mb_use_ext_pgs to enable KTLS.
KTLS is enabled via the KERN_TLS kernel option.
This patch is the culmination of years of work by several folks
including Scott Long and Randall Stewart for the original design and
implementation; Drew Gallatin for several optimizations including the
use of ext_pgs mbufs, the M_NOTREADY mechanism for TLS records
awaiting software encryption, and pluggable software crypto backends;
and John Baldwin for modifications to support hardware TLS offload.
Reviewed by: gallatin, hselasky, rrs
Obtained from: Netflix
Sponsored by: Netflix, Chelsio Communications
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D21277
Finish what was started a few years ago and harmonize IPv6 and IPv4
kernel names. We are down to very few places now that it is feasible
to do the change for everything remaining with causing too much disturbance.
Remove "aliases" for IPv6 names which confusingly could indicate
that we are talking about a different data structure or field or
have two fields, one for each address family.
Try to follow common conventions used in FreeBSD.
* Rename sin6p to sin6 as that is how it is spelt in most places.
* Remove "aliases" (#defines) for:
- in6pcb which really is an inpcb and nothing separate
- sotoin6pcb which is sotoinpcb (as per above)
- in6p_sp which is inp_sp
- in6p_flowinfo which is inp_flow
* Try to use ia6 for in6_addr rather than in6p.
* With all these gone also rename the in6p variables to inp as
that is what we call it in most of the network stack including
parts of netinet6.
The reasons behind this cleanup are that we try to further
unify netinet and netinet6 code where possible and that people
will less ignore one or the other protocol family when doing
code changes as they may not have spotted places due to different
names for the same thing.
No functional changes.
Discussed with: tuexen (SCTP changes)
MFC after: 3 months
Sponsored by: Netflix
Unmapped mbufs allow sendfile to carry multiple pages of data in a
single mbuf, without mapping those pages. It is a requirement for
Netflix's in-kernel TLS, and provides a 5-10% CPU savings on heavy web
serving workloads when used by sendfile, due to effectively
compressing socket buffers by an order of magnitude, and hence
reducing cache misses.
For this new external mbuf buffer type (EXT_PGS), the ext_buf pointer
now points to a struct mbuf_ext_pgs structure instead of a data
buffer. This structure contains an array of physical addresses (this
reduces cache misses compared to an earlier version that stored an
array of vm_page_t pointers). It also stores additional fields needed
for in-kernel TLS such as the TLS header and trailer data that are
currently unused. To more easily detect these mbufs, the M_NOMAP flag
is set in m_flags in addition to M_EXT.
Various functions like m_copydata() have been updated to safely access
packet contents (using uiomove_fromphys()), to make things like BPF
safe.
NIC drivers advertise support for unmapped mbufs on transmit via a new
IFCAP_NOMAP capability. This capability can be toggled via the new
'nomap' and '-nomap' ifconfig(8) commands. For NIC drivers that only
transmit packet contents via DMA and use bus_dma, adding the
capability to if_capabilities and if_capenable should be all that is
required.
If a NIC does not support unmapped mbufs, they are converted to a
chain of mapped mbufs (using sf_bufs to provide the mapping) in
ip_output or ip6_output. If an unmapped mbuf requires software
checksums, it is also converted to a chain of mapped mbufs before
computing the checksum.
Submitted by: gallatin (earlier version)
Reviewed by: gallatin, hselasky, rrs
Discussed with: ae, kp (firewalls)
Relnotes: yes
Sponsored by: Netflix
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D20616
The inp lock is not needed for testing the V6 flag as that flag is set
once when the inp is created and never changes. For non-TCP socket
options the lock is immediately dropped after checking that flag.
This just pushes the lock down to only be acquired for TCP socket
options.
This isn't a hot-path, more a cosmetic cleanup I noticed while reading
the code.
Reviewed by: bz
MFC after: 1 month
Sponsored by: Netflix
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D19740
Limiting the length to 2048 bytes seems to be acceptable, since
the values used right now are using 8 bytes.
Reviewed by: glebius, bz, rrs
MFC after: 3 days
Sponsored by: Netflix, Inc.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D18366
socket resulted in sending fragmented IPV6 packets.
This is fixes by reducing the MSS to the appropriate value. In addtion,
if the socket option is set before the handshake happens, announce this
MSS to the peer. This is not stricly required, but done since TCP
is conservative.
PR: 173444
Reviewed by: bz@, rrs@
MFC after: 1 month
Sponsored by: Netflix, Inc.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D16796
reassembly inbound tcp segments. The old algorithm just blindly
dropped in segments without coalescing. This meant that every
segment could take up greater and greater room on the linked list
of segments. This of course is now subject to a tighter limit (100)
of segments which in a high BDP situation will cause us to be a
lot more in-efficent as we drop segments beyond 100 entries that
we receive. What this restructure does is cause the reassembly
buffer to coalesce segments putting an emphasis on the two
common cases (which avoid walking the list of segments) i.e.
where we add to the back of the queue of segments and where we
add to the front. We also have the reassembly buffer supporting
a couple of debug options (black box logging as well as counters
for code coverage). These are compiled out by default but can
be added by uncommenting the defines.
Sponsored by: Netflix Inc.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D16626
The TCP client side or the TCP server side when not using SYN-cookies
used the uptime as the TCP timestamp value. This patch uses in all
cases an offset, which is the result of a keyed hash function taking
the source and destination addresses and port numbers into account.
The keyed hash function is the same a used for the initial TSN.
Reviewed by: rrs@
MFC after: 1 month
Sponsored by: Netflix, Inc.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D16636
r336940 introduced an "unused variable" warning on platforms which
support INET, but not INET6, like MALTA and MALTA64 as reported
by Mark Millard. Improve the #ifdefs to address this issue.
Sponsored by: Netflix, Inc.
TCP/IPv4 allows an implicit connection setup using sendto(), which
is used for TTCP and TCP fast open. This patch adds support for
TCP/IPv6.
While there, improve some tests for detecting multicast addresses,
which are mapped.
Reviewed by: bz@, kbowling@, rrs@
Sponsored by: Netflix, Inc.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D16458
The following issues are fixed:
* Whenever a TCP server with TCP fast open enabled, calls accept(),
recv(), send(), and close() before the TCP-ACK segment has been received,
the TCP connection is just dropped and the reception of the TCP-ACK
segment triggers the sending of a TCP-RST segment.
* Whenever a TCP server with TCP fast open enabled, calls accept(), recv(),
send(), send(), and close() before the TCP-ACK segment has been received,
the first byte provided in the second send call is not transferred.
* Whenever a TCP client with TCP fast open enabled calls sendto() followed
by close() the TCP connection is just dropped.
Reviewed by: jtl@, kbowling@, rrs@
Sponsored by: Netflix, Inc.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D16485
When ABE was added (rS331214) to NewReno and leak fixed (rS333699) , it now has
a destructor (newreno_cb_destroy) for per connection state. Other congestion
controls may allocate and free cc_data on entry and exit, but the field is
never explicitly NULLed if moving back to NewReno which only internally
allocates stateful data (no entry contstructor) resulting in a situation where
newreno_cb_destory might be called on a junk pointer.
- NULL out cc_data in the framework after calling {cc}_cb_destroy
- free(9) checks for NULL so there is no need to perform not NULL checks
before calling free.
- Improve a comment about NewReno in tcp_ccalgounload
This is the result of a debugging session from Jason Wolfe, Jason Eggleston,
and mmacy@ and very helpful insight from lstewart@.
Submitted by: Kevin Bowling
Reviewed by: lstewart
Sponsored by: Limelight Networks
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D16282
- Add tracker argument to preemptible epochs
- Inline epoch read path in kernel and tied modules
- Change in_epoch to take an epoch as argument
- Simplify tfb_tcp_do_segment to not take a ti_locked argument,
there's no longer any benefit to dropping the pcbinfo lock
and trying to do so just adds an error prone branchfest to
these functions
- Remove cases of same function recursion on the epoch as
recursing is no longer free.
- Remove the the TAILQ_ENTRY and epoch_section from struct
thread as the tracker field is now stack or heap allocated
as appropriate.
Tested by: pho and Limelight Networks
Reviewed by: kbowling at llnw dot com
Sponsored by: Limelight Networks
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D16066
It is the forerunner/foundational work of bringing in both Rack and BBR
which use hpts for pacing out packets. The feature is optional and requires
the TCPHPTS option to be enabled before the feature will be active. TCP
modules that use it must assure that the base component is compile in
the kernel in which they are loaded.
MFC after: Never
Sponsored by: Netflix Inc.
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D15020
tcp_drop() may unlock the INP. Currently, tcp_usr_abort() does not
check for this case, which results in a panic while trying to unlock
the already-unlocked INP (not to mention, a use-after-free violation).
Make tcp_usr_abort() check the return value of tcp_drop(). In the case
where tcp_drop() returns NULL, tcp_usr_abort() can skip further steps
to abort the connection and simply unlock the INP_INFO lock prior to
returning.
Reviewed by: glebius
MFC after: 2 weeks
Sponsored by: Netflix, Inc.
strcpy was used to copy a string into a buffer copied to userland, which
left uninitialized data after the terminating 0-byte. Use the same
approach as in tcp_subr.c: strncpy and explicit '\0'.
admbugs: 765, 822
MFC after: 1 day
Reported by: Ilja Van Sprundel <ivansprundel@ioactive.com>
Reported by: Vlad Tsyrklevich
Security: Kernel memory disclosure
Sponsored by: The FreeBSD Foundation
controlled by the TCP_BLACKBOX option.
Enable this as part of amd64 GENERIC. For now, leave it disabled on
other platforms.
Sponsored by: Netflix, Inc.
summits at BSDCan and BSDCam in 2017.
The TCP Blackbox Recorder allows you to capture events on a TCP connection
in a ring buffer. It stores metadata with the event. It optionally stores
the TCP header associated with an event (if the event is associated with a
packet) and also optionally stores information on the sockets.
It supports setting a log ID on a TCP connection and using this to correlate
multiple connections that share a common log ID.
You can log connections in different modes. If you are doing a coordinated
test with a particular connection, you may tell the system to put it in
mode 4 (continuous dump). Or, if you just want to monitor for errors, you
can put it in mode 1 (ring buffer) and dump all the ring buffers associated
with the connection ID when we receive an error signal for that connection
ID. You can set a default mode that will be applied to a particular ratio
of incoming connections. You can also manually set a mode using a socket
option.
This commit includes only basic probes. rrs@ has added quite an abundance
of probes in his TCP development work. He plans to commit those soon.
There are user-space programs which we plan to commit as ports. These read
the data from the log device and output pcapng files, and then let you
analyze the data (and metadata) in the pcapng files.
Reviewed by: gnn (previous version)
Obtained from: Netflix, Inc.
Relnotes: yes
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D11085
from entering the TIME_WAIT state. However, it omits sending the ACK for the
FIN, which results in RST. This becomes a bigger deal if the sysctl
net.inet.tcp.blackhole is 2. In this case RST isn't send, so the other side of
the connection (also local) keeps retransmitting FINs.
To fix that in tcp_twstart() we will not call tcp_close() immediately. Instead
we will allocate a tcptw on stack and proceed to the end of the function all
the way to tcp_twrespond(), to generate the correct ACK, then we will drop the
last PCB reference.
While here, make a few tiny improvements:
- use bools for boolean variable
- staticize nolocaltimewait
- remove pointless acquisiton of socket lock
Reported by: jtl
Reviewed by: jtl
Sponsored by: Netflix
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D14697
The conditional compilation support is now centralized in
tcp_fastopen.h and tcp_var.h. This doesn't provide the minimum
theoretical code/data footprint when TCP_RFC7413 is disabled, but
nearly all the TFO code should wind up being removed by the optimizer,
the additional footprint in the syncache entries is a single pointer,
and the additional overhead in the tcpcb is at the end of the
structure.
This enables the TCP_RFC7413 kernel option by default in amd64 and
arm64 GENERIC.
Reviewed by: hiren
MFC after: 1 month
Sponsored by: Limelight Networks
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D14048
[RFC7413]. It also includes a pre-shared key mode of operation in
which the server requires the client to be in possession of a shared
secret in order to successfully open TFO connections with that server.
The names of some existing fastopen sysctls have changed (e.g.,
net.inet.tcp.fastopen.enabled -> net.inet.tcp.fastopen.server_enable).
Reviewed by: tuexen
MFC after: 1 month
Sponsored by: Limelight Networks
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D14047
Mainly focus on files that use BSD 3-Clause license.
The Software Package Data Exchange (SPDX) group provides a specification
to make it easier for automated tools to detect and summarize well known
opensource licenses. We are gradually adopting the specification, noting
that the tags are considered only advisory and do not, in any way,
superceed or replace the license texts.
Special thanks to Wind River for providing access to "The Duke of
Highlander" tool: an older (2014) run over FreeBSD tree was useful as a
starting point.
Make sure that the flags INP_IPV4 and INP_IPV6 are consistently set
for inpcbs used for TCP sockets, no matter if the setting is derived
from the net.inet6.ip6.v6only sysctl or the IPV6_V6ONLY socket option.
For UDP this was already done right.
PR: 221385
MFC after: 1 week
if it is called on a TCP socket
* with an IPv6 address and the socket is bound to an
IPv4-mapped IPv6 address.
* with an IPv4-mapped IPv6 address and the socket is bound to an
IPv6 address.
Thanks to Jonathan T. Leighton for reporting this issue.
Reviewed by: bz gnn
MFC after: 3 days
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D9163
Renumber cluase 4 to 3, per what everybody else did when BSD granted
them permission to remove clause 3. My insistance on keeping the same
numbering for legal reasons is too pedantic, so give up on that point.
Submitted by: Jan Schaumann <jschauma@stevens.edu>
Pull Request: https://github.com/freebsd/freebsd/pull/96
Small summary
-------------
o Almost all IPsec releated code was moved into sys/netipsec.
o New kernel modules added: ipsec.ko and tcpmd5.ko. New kernel
option IPSEC_SUPPORT added. It enables support for loading
and unloading of ipsec.ko and tcpmd5.ko kernel modules.
o IPSEC_NAT_T option was removed. Now NAT-T support is enabled by
default. The UDP_ENCAP_ESPINUDP_NON_IKE encapsulation type
support was removed. Added TCP/UDP checksum handling for
inbound packets that were decapsulated by transport mode SAs.
setkey(8) modified to show run-time NAT-T configuration of SA.
o New network pseudo interface if_ipsec(4) added. For now it is
build as part of ipsec.ko module (or with IPSEC kernel).
It implements IPsec virtual tunnels to create route-based VPNs.
o The network stack now invokes IPsec functions using special
methods. The only one header file <netipsec/ipsec_support.h>
should be included to declare all the needed things to work
with IPsec.
o All IPsec protocols handlers (ESP/AH/IPCOMP protosw) were removed.
Now these protocols are handled directly via IPsec methods.
o TCP_SIGNATURE support was reworked to be more close to RFC.
o PF_KEY SADB was reworked:
- now all security associations stored in the single SPI namespace,
and all SAs MUST have unique SPI.
- several hash tables added to speed up lookups in SADB.
- SADB now uses rmlock to protect access, and concurrent threads
can do SA lookups in the same time.
- many PF_KEY message handlers were reworked to reflect changes
in SADB.
- SADB_UPDATE message was extended to support new PF_KEY headers:
SADB_X_EXT_NEW_ADDRESS_SRC and SADB_X_EXT_NEW_ADDRESS_DST. They
can be used by IKE daemon to change SA addresses.
o ipsecrequest and secpolicy structures were cardinally changed to
avoid locking protection for ipsecrequest. Now we support
only limited number (4) of bundled SAs, but they are supported
for both INET and INET6.
o INPCB security policy cache was introduced. Each PCB now caches
used security policies to avoid SP lookup for each packet.
o For inbound security policies added the mode, when the kernel does
check for full history of applied IPsec transforms.
o References counting rules for security policies and security
associations were changed. The proper SA locking added into xform
code.
o xform code was also changed. Now it is possible to unregister xforms.
tdb_xxx structures were changed and renamed to reflect changes in
SADB/SPDB, and changed rules for locking and refcounting.
Reviewed by: gnn, wblock
Obtained from: Yandex LLC
Relnotes: yes
Sponsored by: Yandex LLC
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D9352
after having been dropped.
This fixes enforces in_pcbdrop() logic in tcp_input():
"in_pcbdrop() is used by TCP to mark an inpcb as unused and avoid future packet
delivery or event notification when a socket remains open but TCP has closed."
PR: 203175
Reported by: Palle Girgensohn, Slawa Olhovchenkov
Tested by: Slawa Olhovchenkov
Reviewed by: Slawa Olhovchenkov
Approved by: gnn, Slawa Olhovchenkov
Differential Revision: https://reviews.freebsd.org/D8211
MFC after: 1 week
Sponsored by: Verisign, inc
