This fixes a race condition where another thread may fork() before CLOEXEC
is set, unintentionally passing the descriptor to the child process.
This commit only adds O_CLOEXEC flags to open() or openat() calls where no
fcntl(fd, F_SETFD, FD_CLOEXEC) follows. The separate fcntl() call still
leaves a race window so it should be fixed later.
This method is more sandbox-friendly and also should be faster as only
one syscall is needed instead of three.
In case of an error fall back to the old method.
Reviewed by: simon, gleb
MFC after: 2 weeks
change here is to ensure that when a process forks after arc4random
is seeded, the parent and child don't observe the same random sequence.
OpenBSD's fix introduces some additional overhead in the form of a
getpid() call. This could be improved upon, e.g., by setting a flag
in fork(), if it proves to be a problem.
This was discussed with secteam (simon, csjp, rwatson) in 2008, shortly
prior to my going out of town and forgetting all about it. The conclusion
was that the problem with forks is worrisome, but it doesn't appear to
have introduced an actual vulnerability for any known programs.
The only significant remaining difference between our arc4random and
OpenBSD's is in how we seed the generator in arc4_stir().
OpenBSD's version (r1.22). While some of our style changes were
indeed small improvements, being able to easily track functionality
changes in OpenBSD seems more useful.
Also fix style bugs in the FreeBSD-specific parts of this file.
No functional changes, as verified with md5.
review by secteam@ for the reasons mentioned below.
1) Rename /dev/urandom to /dev/random since urandom marked as
XXX Deprecated
alias in /sys/dev/random/randomdev.c
(this is our naming convention and no review by secteam@ required)
2) Set rs_stired flag after forced initialization to prevent
double stearing.
(this is already in OpenBSD, i.e. they don't have double stearing.
It means that this change matches their code path and no additional
secteam@ review required)
Submitted by: Thorsten Glaser <tg@mirbsd.de> (2)
assumed to be reviewd by them):
Stir directly from the kernel PRNG, without taking less random pid & time
bytes too (when it is possible).
The difference with OpenBSD code is that they have KERN_ARND sysctl for
that task, while we need to read /dev/random
"If you don't get a review within a day or two, I would firmly recommend
backing out the changes"
back out all my changes, i.e. not comes from merging from OpenBSD as
unreviewed by secteam@ yet.
(OpenBSD changes stays in assumption they are reviewd by OpenBSD)
Yes, it means some old bugs returned, like not setted rs_stired = 1 in
arc4random_stir(3) causing double stirring.
1) Unindent and sort variables.
2) Indent struct members.
3) Remove _packed, use guaranteed >128 bytes size and only first 128
bytes from the structure.
4) Reword comment.
Obtained from: bde
2) Use gettimeofday() and getpid() only if reading from /dev/urandom
fails or impossible.
3) Discard N bytes on very first initialization only (i.e. don't
discard on re-stir).
4) Reduce N from 1024 to 512 as really suggested in the
"(Not So) Random Shuffles of RC4" paper:
http://research.microsoft.com/users/mironov/papers/rc4full.pdf
2) Eliminate "struct arc4_stream *as" arg since only single arg is
possible.
3) Set rs.j = rs.i after arc4random key schedule to be more like arc4
stream cipher.
Obtained from: OpenBSD
adding (weak definitions to) stubs for some of the pthread
functions. If the threads library is linked in, the real
pthread functions will pulled in.
Use the following convention for system calls wrapped by the
threads library:
__sys_foo - actual system call
_foo - weak definition to __sys_foo
foo - weak definition to __sys_foo
Change all libc uses of system calls wrapped by the threads
library from foo to _foo. In order to define the prototypes
for _foo(), we introduce namespace.h and un-namespace.h
(suggested by bde). All files that need to reference these
system calls, should include namespace.h before any standard
includes, then include un-namespace.h after the standard
includes and before any local includes. <db.h> is an exception
and shouldn't be included in between namespace.h and
un-namespace.h namespace.h will define foo to _foo, and
un-namespace.h will undefine foo.
Try to eliminate some of the recursive calls to MT-safe
functions in libc/stdio in preparation for adding a mutex
to FILE. We have recursive mutexes, but would like to avoid
using them if possible.
Remove uneeded includes of <errno.h> from a few files.
Add $FreeBSD$ to a few files in order to pass commitprep.
Approved by: -arch
just use _foo() <-- foo(). In the case of a libpthread that doesn't do
call conversion (such as linuxthreads and our upcoming libpthread), this
is adequate. In the case of libc_r, we still need three names, which are
now _thread_sys_foo() <-- _foo() <-- foo().
Convert all internal libc usage of: aio_suspend(), close(), fsync(), msync(),
nanosleep(), open(), fcntl(), read(), and write() to _foo() instead of foo().
Remove all internal libc usage of: creat(), pause(), sleep(), system(),
tcdrain(), wait(), and waitpid().
Make thread cancellation fully POSIX-compliant.
Suggested by: deischen
points. For library functions, the pattern is __sleep() <--
_libc_sleep() <-- sleep(). The arrows represent weak aliases. For
system calls, the pattern is _read() <-- _libc_read() <-- read().
srandomdev(), but can be used inside libraries. random() can't be used
inside libraries because it breaks its possible predictable sequence.
arc4random() is true random as designed, so its usage is library-safe.
Obtained from: OpenBSD
